Nov 22, 2019

Documentary Provides Rare Look at Higher Education in Prison

Educating inmates is cheaper than locking them up again, in addition to being the right thing to do. A new PBS documentary goes behind the scenes.
By Mneesha Gellman/Emerson College /
Documentary Provides Rare Look at Higher Education in Prison
Students in an advanced bachelor’s degree seminar in the Bard Prison Initiative at Eastern New York Correctional Facility. Skiff Mountain Films

What is prison for? Should it include a college education?

Those two questions are at the heart of “College Behind Bars,” a new documentary that airs Nov. 25 and 26 on PBS. The documentary – by Lynn Novick and produced by Sarah Botstein and Ken Burns – offers a rare, up-close look at how offering higher education in a correctional facility can change lives.

The Bard Prison Initiative, a college-in-prison program in New York state, is the focal point of the documentary.

As a political science scholar who has taught behind bars – and as one of the first student volunteers for the Bard Prison Initiative – I’ve seen firsthand the transformative power that prison education programs can have.

My first experience with the Initiative came in the early 2000s when I was an an undergraduate at Bard College. Back then, I volunteered at Eastern Correctional Facility, where I tutored a social science class; and at Beacon Correctional Facility, a women’s minimum security prison, where I helped lead a writing workshop. Both prisons are located in New York state. It was powerful to see how students acquired new skills for analysis and self-expression – and how it allowed them to engage differently with their worlds.

In 2017, after becoming a political science professor at Emerson College, I used my experience and the Bard Prison Initiative as a model to launch the Emerson Prison Initiative. The idea behind the Initiative is to expand access to higher education to incarcerated people in Massachusetts.

Dollars and sense

Even if you don’t view education for the incarcerated as a worthy social justice issue, it is – at a minimum – a matter of saving taxpayer money.

Massachusetts taxpayers, for instance, pay an average of US$45,000-$70,000 per year to incarcerate someone in state prison. This is about the same amount that it would cost to attend Emerson.

Whereas the vast majority of formerly incarcerated people – five out of six – end up getting arrested again within nine years, among graduates of the Bard Prison Initiative, 97% never go back to prison.

What prison should do

The new “College Behind Bars” documentary goes deeper than dollars and sense, though. It pushes viewers to consider the purpose of prison and who has access to education.

These questions are all the more important given the fact that one in two adults, according to the advocacy group, has had a family member in jail or prison at some point. Of the 6.6 million adults incarcerated or under supervision – that is, in jail, prison, on probation or parole – nearly 2.2 million are actually behind bars at any given time.

In theory, incarceration is supposed to deter people from committing further crimes. But recidivism – or reverting to crime after being released from prison – can be as high as 83%.

This raises questions about whether correctional facilities are, in fact, correctional in nature. In my experience – and based on what the research shows – correctional facilities are more effective when they provide education. For instance, a 2014 Rand Corporation study showed that educational programming of any type reduces recidivism by 43%. The same study found that educational access, rather than particular characteristics of students, is what breaks recidivism.

College standards

But it can’t be just any kind of education. The Bard Prison Initiative, for instance, rigorously applies the same high standards used at Bard College to its college in prison. The same is true for the Emerson Prison Initiative that I founded. To get into the program, which is offered at Massachusetts Correctional Institution at Concord, students are vetted in an admissions process that includes a timed essay, scored by a panel of five faculty and administrators, and a second round in-person interview. Applicants are not asked to say why they are in prison, but rather to demonstrate what they want to do with their minds.

Students in the Emerson Prison Initiative are working on an interdisciplinary bachelor’s degree in media, literature and culture. Faculty teach courses in topics that range from world theater to business mathematics. The bachelor of arts at Concord follows the same requirements as a degree from Emerson College. Assignments are also graded the same they are at Emerson College. Graduation for this first group of students is planned for summer 2022.

The vast majority of students in the program will ultimately be released back into society. This brings to mind a question raised by one of the women featured in the “College Behind Bars” documentary. To paraphrase, she said: Who do you want to be your neighbor? The person who gets released, moves next door and is going to plot on your house, or the one who got educated inside, gets a job when they come out and now you have barbecues together?

Impact of education

The other day, students in the Emerson Prison Initiative had a chance to screen “College Behind Bars.” The documentary prompted them to reflect on what it means to have access to college education in prison.

One student, Maurice, stated: “Before, I had nothing. No visits. No understanding of my situation. No purpose or guidance. I was on a path for destruction. An opportunity was presented and my life has changed dramatically since being enrolled in the Emerson Prison Initiative. It is my life.”

Another student, Kevin, stated that the Emerson Prison Initiative has given him a new sense of purpose.

“For the first time in my life, I know what I want,” Kevin said. “What’s the point of being physically free if not mentally? It’s through education that I’ll be liberated. And that’s what I want.”

After seeing Bard Prison Initiative students in the film discuss how they apply skills from college, Mac, who prepares his course work on a typewriter, says “The limits of my degree are only set by my own thinking.”

People released from prison with college degrees are much more likely to find gainful employment, support themselves financially, pay taxes and contribute to their communities. This shows that educational access behind bars creates opportunities that contribute to the public good, save taxpayer dollars and makes society safer and more prosperous.

Expanding access to higher education through programs like Emerson Prison Initiative and Bard Prison Initiative requires rethinking what prison is for, and what responsibility colleges and universities have to expand access to higher education.

[ Deep knowledge, daily. Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter. ]The Conversation

Mneesha Gellman, Associate Professor of Political Science, Emerson College

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Rate this article 
Police & Prisons
Anti-Racism is a Big Movement: Here are Some of the Conversations & Ideas That You May Have Missed
Transition Documentaries
Trending Videos
Why Trump Is Partnering With Christian Nationalists | Robert Reich
6 min - Donald Trump keeps comparing himself to Jesus. Whether he actually has a messiah complex or is just conning his supporters, he's playing to a growing GOP faction that wants America to be a white...
Investigating Trump, Project 2025 and the Future of the United States | Four Corners (2024)
56 min - There has never been a US president like Donald Trump — and now he’s back, this time with a detailed plan for his second coming. Nearly four years after he was cast out by voters and accused of...
TraumaZone (2022)
350 min - An epic documentary by British director Adam Curtis illustrating in seven parts state and decline of the Soviet Union and the development in Russia 1985–1999 using material from the BBC archives.
Trending Articles
Thought-Provoking Comics
Reading Library
Subscribe for $5/mo to Watch over 50 Patron-Exclusive Films


Become a Patron. Support Films For Action.

For $5 a month, you'll gain access to over 50 patron-exclusive documentaries while keeping us ad-free and financially independent. We need 350 more Patrons to grow our team in 2024.

Subscribe | Explore the 50+ Patron Films

Our 6000+ video library is 99% free, ad-free, and entirely community-funded thanks to our patrons!

Before you subscribe, please note:
We have lots of films in our library that are Pay-Per-View only, which aren't available by becoming a Subscriber. 

If you're subscribing to watch a particular film, please check the film's page for access details. Patron Films have this button below the video: