What does Superman tell us about the ethics of closed borders? Superman was created in 1938 by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster, two sons of Jewish immigrants, and his origin story is fundamentally a refugee narrative: a child launched from a dying world, taken in by strangers, raised as one of their own. That parallel has always been there, but it takes on a sharper edge when set against actual history. The Kindertransport saved thousands of Jewish children by sending them to live with families in Britain. The passengers of the MS St. Louis were turned away from American shores and sent back to Europe, where many perished. Superman made it to Smallville. Not everyone gets Smallville.
From that foundation, the video builds a thorough dismantlement of modern anti-immigration arguments. Data consistently shows immigrants commit violent crimes at lower rates than native-born citizens. The "stolen jobs" narrative collapses under scrutiny, with natural experiments like the 1980 Mariel boatlift demonstrating that large influxes of workers had negligible long-term effects on unemployment or wages. The "we're full" claim falls apart against actual population density figures. And the history of restrictive U.S. immigration law, from the Chinese Exclusion Act through the Johnson-Reed Act of 1924, reveals roots tangled deep in eugenics and institutionalized racism. Today's rhetoric isn't a departure from that legacy; it's a continuation.
There's also a pointed critique of liberal centrism here. "Reasonable" immigration reform, in practice, has meant center-left administrations overseeing massive deportation operations while congratulating themselves on their compassion. The argument is that half-measures do more to protect the political status quo than to protect people, and that explicitly championing open borders is the only way to shift the Overton window toward justice. A mixed review of James Gunn's 2025 Superman film sharpens the point: for all its humanist intentions, the movie ultimately frames Kryptonians as a genuine foreign threat, inadvertently echoing the xenophobic narratives it claims to oppose.
The closing call is collective. Politics, at its core, is something people do together. No lone hero, however super, substitutes for organized action. - FFA
Corrections:
- I state MS13 is a Mexican gang, they are actually Salvadoran
- I state that the largest mass lynching in US history happened in LA in 1971, it was actually 1871 (as per the text on the screen)
Support this project on Patreon at https://patreon.com/ericrosenfield
Full text with citations: https://literatemachine.com/2026/01/19/superman-and-the-case-for-open-borders/