Does Israel Have a ‘Right to Exist’? Mehdi Debunks This ‘Bullsh*t’ Argument

In this video, journalist Mehdi Hasan breaks down why the demand to recognize "Israel's right to exist" functions less as a genuine question and more as a rhetorical tool designed to shut down critical conversation about Israel's policies. He offers three key counter-arguments:

Ambiguous Borders: Israel is the only country that refuses to define its own borders. So when someone invokes this "right," it's worth asking: which Israel? Does that include Gaza, the West Bank, the Golan Heights, and East Jerusalem—territories considered illegally occupied under international law?

The Nature of Rights: Rights belong to people, not states. Countries are political constructs that evolve, dissolve, and reconstitute over time—the USSR, Yugoslavia, and Czechoslovakia being just a few examples. There is no legal or natural principle granting any state the right to exist in perpetuity.

Double Standards on Palestine: The same voices demanding recognition of Israel's existence have actively blocked Palestine's right to statehood at the UN. This kind of demand is rarely, if ever, applied to any other nation—revealing it as propaganda rather than a principled stance.

Mehdi encourages viewers not to be thrown by this common "gotcha" question, arguing that the focus should remain on Israel's actions—including its apartheid practices, war crimes, and the ongoing devastation in Gaza.

Subscribe to Zeteo to support independent and unfiltered journalism: https://zeteo.com/subscribe

LOVE FILMS FOR ACTION?
We don't run on ads. We're run on community. Donating $5/month makes a difference. Subscribe here.
Media Literacy Explore All
Beyond Elections: Redefining Democracy and the Promise of a Million Utopias
Trending Videos Explore All
Trending Articles Explore All
Recent Documentaries Explore All
Video Deep Dives Explore All
What People Are Watching Now
Long Videos
Recently Added
Support independent media that amplifies real voices and movements. 



Subscribe for $5/month to become a patron and watch over 50 patron-exclusive documentaries.

Share this: