Dec 19, 2024

Why People Hate Socialism—And What It Actually Is

By Tim Hjersted / filmsforaction.org

Socialism is one of the most vilified and misunderstood ideas in modern political discourse. The number one reason for this hatred? Most people have no idea what socialism actually is. Decades of propaganda have reduced the concept to caricatures of authoritarian states and failed economies. Let’s clear that up—and do it kindly.
 

 

Socialism isn’t about state control of everything. It’s not about bureaucrats seizing your paycheck or telling you what kind of car to drive. At its core, socialism is about democracy—real democracy—applied to the economy. It’s the radical notion that the people who do the work should have a say in how their workplaces and resources are run.

Market Socialism

Let’s start with market socialism. Imagine an economy where businesses aren’t controlled by a handful of CEOs and investors but by the workers themselves.

This isn’t fantasy—worker cooperatives exist all over the world. According to the International Cooperative Alliance, there are approximately 3 million cooperatives worldwide, employing an estimated 280 million people. Take Mondragon Corporation in Spain, where workers collectively own and manage the company. Profits are shared, decisions are democratic, and the enterprise still competes in the market. That’s market socialism: a system where workplaces are accountable to the people who create the value, not to distant shareholders.

Another term for market socialism is workplace socialism. Think of it as applying democracy to the places we spend most of our lives: our jobs. In a worker self-directed enterprise (WSDE), decisions about hiring, wages, and policies are made collectively by the workers. This isn’t some abstract ideal. Companies like Equal Exchange, a cooperative specializing in fair trade goods, operate this way right now. Means TV is another example. Workers earn fairly, have a say in decisions, and still thrive in competitive markets.

Socialism in Government 

Socialism in government is the elephant in the room, but again, we have decades of precedent that show it's just not that scary when we look at modern examples, which are almost universally situated within mixed-market economies.

Countries like Sweden, Denmark, Norway, and Finland combine strong social welfare systems with thriving private sectors. They offer universal healthcare, subsidized education, and robust social safety nets while fostering innovation and entrepreneurship. Germany has publicly owned utilities and a strong system of worker representation through "co-determination," where employees participate in corporate decision-making.

Not Scary in Practice:

Many socialist principles already operate in ways people accept without fear. 

For instance:

-Public libraries provide free access to information.

-Public roads are maintained through collective taxation.

-Fire departments and police services are government-run to ensure equitable access, regardless of income.

These systems are socialism in action but aren't typically framed that way in everyday discussions.

Here's what most social democratic governments have in common today:

-Decentralized and Democratic: Modern examples of socialism in mixed-market economies are decentralized and responsive to democratic input, avoiding authoritarian pitfalls of 20th-century models like the Soviet Union, which scholars like Noam Chomsky classified as state capitalism. With state capitalism, the state owns the means of production but retains the authoritarian structure of modern capitalist enterprises.

-Targeted Interventions: Modern socialist policies often address specific areas—healthcare, utilities, education—where market mechanisms fail to provide equitable or efficient solutions.

-Economic Balance: Mixed-market economies allow private enterprise to flourish while addressing inequalities and market failures through public systems.

The real "elephant in the room" is that socialism is already a foundational element in many successful societies. It's not an abstract threat but an integrated part of systems people rely on daily. When framed this way, it becomes less about ideology and more about pragmatism: How do we structure systems to work better for everyone?

Decades of precedent show that a balance of socialist principles within a market framework is not only workable but often highly effective.

Public Goods

The core of socialism in government is about addressing public goods—services too essential to be left to the whims of private profit. Public utilities like water and electricity systems are prime examples. When privatized, these services often gouge consumers and prioritize profits over reliability. Publicly owned utilities, however, prioritize affordability and access because they are accountable to the public, not shareholders.

Consider public banking. States like North Dakota run public banks that reinvest profits into local communities instead of enriching Wall Street. Or public energy systems, like those in Nebraska, where the power grid is entirely owned by the people, ensuring affordable rates and renewable investments.

Socialized healthcare offers perhaps the clearest example of modern socialism integrated into a mixed-market economy. Systems like Medicare in the U.S. or the National Health Service in the UK aren’t about government overreach—they’re about ensuring that healthcare is a right, not a privilege.

Socialized healthcare costs less too. Medicare in the US operates with administrative costs of around 2% of total expenditures. The low percentage reflects Medicare's efficiency as a single-payer system without the need for profit margins or elaborate marketing.

Private insurers typically spend 12-18% of total expenditures on administrative costs. This includes marketing, underwriting, executive compensation, profit margins, and complex claims management processes. A portion of these costs also goes toward denying claims and negotiating with providers—activities largely unnecessary in Medicare.

All in all, these ideas—cooperatives, WSDEs, public utilities, and universal healthcare—aren’t about dismantling markets or innovation. They’re about rebalancing power and ensuring the economy works for everyone, not just the wealthy few. Socialism in this sense isn’t a rigid ideology but a practical toolbox for creating a fairer, more democratic society.

If you’ve been taught to hate socialism, ask yourself: Why is worker control scarier than billionaire control? Why is public energy scarier than private monopolies? Why is collective ownership worse than exploitation and having no say at work? Once you understand what socialism truly is, you might find it’s not so scary after all. You might even realize it’s already working in places you admire.

Big Ideas   Economics   Human Rights   Media Literacy   Politics   Solutions
Rate this article 
Media Literacy
Trending Videos
Anonymous Issues DIRE WARNING To MAGA | The Kyle Kulinski Show
11 min - Anonymous has released a new video warning about the growing threats posed by Trump, JD Vance, and Elon Musk. They outline how economic policies, mass firings, and regulatory rollbacks are...
Carl Sagan's Cosmos: A Personal Voyage (1980)
780 min - Astronomer Carl Sagan's landmark 13-part science series takes you on an awe-inspiring cosmic journey to the edge of the Universe and back aboard the spaceship of the imagination.The series was...
How Oil Propaganda Sneaks Into TV Shows | Climate Town
32 min - Not everything fictional characters say is true.Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/ClimateTown 
How Peter Thiel Got Rich | Second Thought (2022)
12 min - Billionaire Peter Thiel won big in the midterms, buying himself a Senate seat in Ohio. So what does Thiel want? Unfettered corporate power and the destruction of government institutions. This...
HyperNormalisation (2016)
161 min - We live in a time of great uncertainty and confusion. Events keep happening that seem inexplicable and out of control. Donald Trump, Brexit, the War in Syria, the endless migrant crisis, random...
Oligarchs Are Our Modern Day Kings
10 min - Billionaires like Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg, and Jeff Bezos aren’t just amassing wealth—they’re consolidating power, shaping government policy, and controlling the flow of information. As the...
How a Land High in the Western Himalayas Can Help Us Understand The Crisis of The Modern World
9 min - This is a clip from The Economics of Happiness. Watch it here (skip to the 10-minute mark to pick up where this clip ends) It's a brilliant film that was easy to put at the top of our list of the...
Trending Articles
Ecovillages: Experiments in New and Ancient Ways of Living
How the "Mainstream" Media Misleads
Subscribe for $5/mo to Watch over 50 Patron-Exclusive Films
Subscribe $5/mo View All Patron Films

 

Your support keeps us ad-free and financially independent

Our 10,000+ video & article library is 99% free, ad-free, and entirely community-funded thanks to our patron subscribers!


Want to donate extra? You can subscribe and donate an extra $5/mo or more.