Oct 29, 2026
8 min read

We Need a Movement for Self-rule – and It’s a Play

At some point(s) in our history we had the ability to govern ourselves ripped from us, and concentrated in the hands of kings and aristocrats, then governments, and now, it seems, tech bros, private equity, and banks too big to fail. Clare Farrell argues the root solution is an “everything movement” that leads to real democracy, and that means self-rule.
By Clare Farrell / clarejfarrell.substack.com
We Need a Movement for Self-rule – and It’s a Play
A role for everyone in building World 2. Image (cc) Andreas Pliatsikas.

What I want to do in this post is outline an idea that’s still forming, of why the movement we need now might be a massive national play with a cast of seventy million.

Inhabiting a movement for self-rule

If the movement we need – in an era of climate calamity – is, as I wrote last week, an “everything movement” that leads to real democracy, that means it’s a movement for self-rule.

A movement for self-rule is what I think we’ve been working on (collectively, across many different regions, organizations and groups) for many years.

It’s the logical response to the failures of the existing neoliberal paradigm in maintaining our basic life support systems: the food system, the water system, the climate system, etc. At some point(s) in our history we had the ability to govern ourselves ripped from us, and concentrated in the hands of kings and aristocrats, then governments, and now, it seems, tech bros, private equity, and banks too big to fail.

You could call this failing system World 1. These bad actors are driving us to our deaths. So we have to take rule back into our own hands. We have to lead the way to World 2, and act as if we really are in charge and are already building it.

To do this, I have reset my strategic orientation, and that of the people I collaborate with, from a single movement- or organisational- view, towards a diverse and complex eco-systemic approach; beyond a narrow cause-and-effect logic that can give you great tactics but does not provide a system-changing strategy.

This movement for self-rule is more clearly about work that can actually change the system. From World 1 to World 2.

World 2

I believe that we are moving towards an absolute clusterfuck situation, where systems break. T-I-N-A (Thatcher’s famous “there is no alternative”) has left us divided, weak, alone, and afraid, with a grave lack of agency.

Now is the inflection point. Because only at the point of total belief that no one is coming to save us, will people invest everything they have in moving from World 1 to World 2.

The work remains a hearts and minds job. You do need the right information in front of you to understand how utterly and systemically, totally fucked everything is, so that you will turn your life’s work into the constructive rebuilding of absolutely everything. Once you see what is going on in the data, in our cascading systems collapse, you will know that the future is more fun if you are swept up in the thrill of making a new world than clinging to a collapsing shitshow and feeling miserable. And the sooner we start, the more we have that we can work with.

And it has to be fun, enjoyable, challenging, and collective. Which is why it has to be culturally-led, to allow people to dream, imagine, take up a role, act, rehearse without fear, and get performing. That’s why I think the movement for self-rule we need is a play with characters people can inhabit.

The Play: suspension of bad-beliefs!

The problem we face is that a majority of people have come to inhabit the story of T-I-N-A and so they really do believe there is no alternative.

What we need to do is overcome this neoliberalism paradigm which has trapped people in self-destruct cycles because they believe there is no alternative. Friends call this belief a “deep disposition” that guides people’s lives and habits, their attitudes and behaviours.

Our job is to help people believe there IS an alternative. We have to get to people deep down, not just their thoughts, but into what they often don’t even realise is a deeply held disposition or belief.

As my friend Charlie says, “the nation that plays together stays together”. Playing together boosts trust, confidence and relationships. I think playing a role and inhabiting that role with others can help do this.

A word on acting like you’re in charge

One of the main reasons why I have been celebrating the National Emergency Briefing on the climate crisis is that they have self-organised something which is statesperson-like.

But more specifically, for me, they have taken the lead where the government is missing in action, and they’re acting as if they’re in charge.

You will notice if you pay attention that many people in politics succeed simply by acting as if they are in charge, when really they’re not in charge of anything.

Others wrestle with reality and say, “Well, I can affect that, but I can’t affect this, and I’m going to be honest with you, this is difficult, or that can happen and that can’t happen”. But the people who inhabit a confident narrative, where they assume a lead position in pulling everybody forwards into a story that they dominate, seem to build themselves up an enormous amount of power, and often remarkably quickly.

If we could assume this work in that mode of inhabiting this story, with confidence, with the suspension of disbelief that is required for us to believe that we are not just capable of, but already doing self-rule, then I think we could make strides extremely quickly.

R&D: making the play

In my version, the roles in the play that we would inhabit:

  • are very specific
  • serve different relational needs
  • often reflect what people are already doing, but help people reinhabit the larger story
  • come with outfits

If you were playing out our new World 2, what job would you do?

You could choose to be statesman-like like the people behind the National Emergency Briefing. Or you could be a healer of communities, a story wallah, a process nerd, a power broker or a diplomat, a social entrepreneur, a therapist, an artist. Are you holding and hospicing pain or running ahead with bright eyes and naive hope?

We might not feel ready for the opening night, but we’ve got to get on with it

It won’t all have to be perfect, and we don’t have to have every job ticked off.

What’s going to be important is that whatever is built has an ecological view, where we are put back in our place as humans, as part of the living world, not the supreme people in charge of the universe. That’s Elon Musk’s job, and I’m sure he’ll do it great from his headquarters in Mars. What’s also important is that we recognize how damaged everything is, and that the future will have to be built to be regenerative by design.

What matters is being collective

What matters is how we are developing people (and ourselves) in collective ways. The work now has to be making things together, a living, breathing practice of making the new World 2 together that moves as a process and is in relationship to itself. We have to get people into Doing Mode, not thinking or showing up sometimes, but to be doing things together over the long term.

This Doing Together is key. We have to get into a flow of doing, making, building. (It’s ‘work’ we need to do, but in a ‘your life’s work’ kind of way, not a 9-5 kind of way.)

And there’s no better way to get people to do something that might feel difficult or scary or challenging than to first of all get people to simply pretend, play, or act in that way.

How it might work in place

I’m talking to a lot of people right now about how this might work. How we might land in a place, convene the ‘150’ organisers, activists, artists, already doing the work, and help them play, re-inhabit and re-dream their work into a bigger story: not simply of making the best of World 1 where they live, but making the leap into World 2.

What are the other roles we need in this play? What are the systems of psychology (like Robert Schwarz’s Internal Family Systems) or systems of theatre (like forum theatre) that we can learn from in developing this idea? I’m talking to brilliant people such as Ruth Ben-Tovim at Town Anywhere and of course my friends at Dash Arts. Who else can I be learning from? Questions I’m asking are: how can the play help develop perspectives in ecological ways? How can we improvise in real time? Can it accommodate the bridge builders and agitators?

It’s not all rosy and frictionless. As we noted in XR’s story circle back in 2022, in an ecosystem some things fight and some things eat one another! But it is ‘being’ a form of intelligence, self-perpetuating and learning through doing and experience.

Dreaming the new reality

We have to dream ourselves into a new ecological reality.

The issue up to now has been that some humans have imagined some systems into existence – like permanent growth – which cannot survive their contact with reality on the earth. But because some people really benefit from these systems, at the expense of the vast majority of us, they defend their systems with violence, even as they destroy the very ecological reality that underpins survival.

It’s the paradox that we must imagine and dream the new whilst making sure it is realistic in terms of earth systems, energy and material and life itself. The skill we need for this is reality-bound dreaming. And where else better to rehearse this skill than inside a play?

Humility, Empathy, Frugality

We did a lot of this work during XR. It was our ambition to dream into reality a new regenerative culture.

I still think the best banners we ever did were the Empathy, Humility, Frugality banners. At the time they were unfashionable words. But they summed up what we were trying to do. Before XR, when I created the Bodypolitic project with Miles Glyn, it was out of an early recognition of the lack of spiritual thought and support structures in our society to help shift the system. So it necessarily went to this language because the ideas we need are around the transcendent and the sacred.

Miles at work on the banners. Image © Miles Gyln.

The questions: “what are you even alive for and what are you doing with that life?” were, I think, a major attractor for the ecologically-conscious membership, and probably was a reason for so much confused response to XR from the materialist left. That’s because we were moving people into a perspective of being and becoming; and out of the mode of having, acquisition, or even of achievement. Virtue ethics, not utilitarianism.

It is the practice of being, acting, listening and then doing that appealed to the ecologically minded, who know that the problem is that we are not, as a society, in right relation to the reality of the problem. And the problem is that some humans have dreamed up a system of supremacy over nature (and over each other) that leaves us very much not in right relation to the ecological, the planet, or each other.

It is a path we’re on; a real movement

Elon Musk says, “I’m going over there because over here is fucked, and that means Mars.”

The far right are saying, “the system’s fucked, we’re going over there to the right, to the white ethno-nationalist, supremacist, authoritarian state”.

So when we say “the system’s fucked, we’re going over there” for us “over there” has to be towards a place-based, commons-grounded, interconnected society and bioregional economies based on love, care and freedom. It is play. It is diverse and multicultural. It is digging down into the grassroots and down to the ground.

It also means going down into the self, our inner experience of life and re-enchanting ourselves with the miracle of living and breathing on this magically beautiful Earth.

KEEP OUR LIBRARY FREE
$5/month keep us freely available to all. No paywalls for 99% of content, no ads, just people-powered media. Subscribe here.
Community Explore All
Popular This Month
Trending Videos Explore All
Trending Articles Explore All
Recent Documentaries Explore All
Video Deep Dives Explore All
What People Are Watching Now
Videos by Second Thought
Recently Added
Support independent media for a more free, regenerative and democratic society. 



Subscribe for $5/month to support us and watch over 50 patron-exclusive documentaries.

Share this:

Share