Something happened on the American left in the last couple of years. Figures like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Zohran Mamdani started publicly distancing themselves from the language and style of politics that defined progressive culture in the early 2020s. Harper O'Connor's video essay asks what that shift actually means and whether it goes deep enough.
O'Connor's argument is that the problem was never the values themselves but a specific mode of politics — purity testing, virtue signaling, symbolic gestures like Nancy Pelosi donning Kente cloth — that substituted performance for power. Drawing on Musa al-Gharbi's work, the video frames this style of politics as a kind of status currency for professionals in media, academia, and nonprofits, one that had very little to do with the material interests of working people and, in many cases, actively alienated them.
The prescription is a return to labor-based organizing and long-term institution building. O'Connor points to historical examples like the German Social Democratic Party, which built an entire counterculture of clubs, libraries, and voluntary associations that created durable solidarity across difference. His argument is that a "post-woke" rebrand means nothing without this kind of infrastructure. Dropping the language while keeping the same subculture mentality just produces a shinier version of the same dead end. What the left actually needs is a multi-decade commitment to building organizations rooted in working-class life.