Nov 18, 2023

What I Learned From Reading Osama Bin Laden's 2002 "Letter to America"

By Tim Hjersted /
What I Learned From Reading Osama Bin Laden's 2002 "Letter to America"
The letter published in the Guardian in 2002 has since been removed following a surge in traffic from TikTok. The letter has resurfaced in the context of Israel's war against Hamas, given that many in the West did not know that America's war crimes in the Middle East and support for Israel's occupation of Palestine was the prime excuse for the 9/11 attacks.

What did I learn from reading Osama Bin Laden's 2002 Letter to America? I learned how every villain, no matter how cartoonish we might cast their motives (they hate us for our freedoms), always has an internal logic that casts themselves as moral and just.

Bid Laden justified the killing of American civilians by throwing our false slogans about Americans having freedom back in our faces. According to Bin Laden, because we freely elected presidents who are guilty of war crimes (which is the sadly true part), Americans are complicit in their crimes and thus fair targets for retribution.

This logic is the logic of terrorism and should rightly be rejected. No one deserves to die because they voted in an election.

Besides the false moral justification, this is also a false theory because Americans do not have a real democracy. Our choices are rigged and always involve two pro-war choices. Not everyone supports America's wars or even voted for those who wage those wars, and millions of Americans actively protest the crimes of their government, to no avail usually because we are ruled by criminals aided by a complicit corporate media (but I digress).

Tragically, Bid Laden is not alone in using the facade of elections to justify war crimes. Today, those who support Israel's war on Hamas justify the killing of 13,000+ Palestinians because they say Gazans voted for Hamas in 2006, making them complicit and thus fair game for attack. It's the "you reap what you sow" line of argument. Just today, a commenter on Films For Action's Facebook page told us "If Hamas wins elections based on terrorism then Gaza deserves what it gets."

Many hard-right Israel supporters say the quiet part out loud and claim there are no innocent people in Gaza at all (even, apparently, the children, which is almost half the population). This is even coming from Israel's president, Isaac Herzog:

"It is an entire nation out there that is responsible,” Herzog said at a press conference in October. “It is not true this rhetoric about civilians not being aware, not involved. It’s absolutely not true. They could have risen up. They could have fought against that evil regime which took over Gaza in a coup d’etat.” 

"The residents of Gaza are not innocent.  They elected Hamas… they chose this freely and must live with the consequences”. - Gilad Sharon (2012)

Again, besides being morally bankrupt and in violation of international standards against the war crime of collective punishment, this is a false theory because less than 50% voted for Hamas and most of the people in Gaza today weren't old enough to vote then. If Americans can't rise up and oust their criminal presidents from power or sway them to do the right thing, even in a so-called democracy, even with millions protesting, how can we expect the people of Gaza to, when Hamas is known for their brutal repression of dissent? 

Less die-hard pro-war supporters will claim they care about minimizing civilian casualties, and yet they nonetheless support military tactics that lead to a 74-94% civilian death rate. 

We know pro-war supporters share the logic of Bin Laden because they condone the bombing campaign on Gaza, which has killed over 5000 unmistakably innocent children, but they excuse it by saying Gazans are human shields, and Hamas must be defeated even at the cost of civilian casualties.

We know pro-war supporters share this logic because, without question, we know they would not support this bombing campaign if Hamas was hiding inside Israel. They absolutely would not support the killing of 13,000+ Israeli civilians and the bombing of their own country, and this right here reveals the violent nationalism (and yes, obfuscated terrorism) inherent in pro-war logic. Israeli lives simply matter far more than Palestinian lives. Such high civilian casualties would never be excused if the victims were Israeli or American. 

Supporters of Hamas, like Bin Laden, likewise believe Israeli civilians are not innocent (due to implicit support for the occupation and the election of pro-occuation leaders) and are thus fair targets for attack. Such logic must be condemned no matter who promotes it. Millions of Jewish people around the world are against the occupation, Israel's war and do not support Netanyahu. Numerous Israeli citizens are protesting their government as we speak, and many opposed to Israel's occupation died during the Oct 7th attack, such is the tragic logic of totalizing narratives, which cast entire groups as the enemy.

So let's be clear: To support Hamas or Israel's government right now is to support the logic of collective punishment, which is a war crime under international law. Even if an American, Palestinian or Israeli citizen helped elect a criminal political party, no citizen deserves to be targeted with violence or killed based on a vote in an election, which is usually rigged anyway. If we can agree that collective punishment is wrong, this much should not be contested.

What is truly appalling to me, if we are now ready to lift the veil of ideologically-induced delusion from our eyes, is that the government of Israel has now committed over four 9/11s on the people of Palestine and pro-war supporters cheer for this (in the name of defeating Hamas) and hope "Israel finishes the job" as we saw at one major pro-war rally.

This is true insanity. George Bush, Netanyahu, Osama Bin Laden, Joe Biden, Putin, Trump, and all pro-war supporters are alike in that they all invoke one justification or another for civilian casualties in the name of a greater good.

I absolutely reject this logic no matter who promotes it, but I will speak out against it even more so when it comes from the leaders in my own government or its allies.

Violence will never lead to peace. Only a political solution can accomplish that.


Tim Hjersted is a co-founder of Films For Action. All of his articles are released under Creative Commons to freely republish.

Related Films
Yes, For Historical Literacy, You Should Read Bin Laden's TikTok-Viral "Letter to America" | Glenn Greenwald
24 min · "Osama Bin Laden was a terrorist who rationalized the killing of innocent civilians by claiming they were not innocent (arguing Americans freely elected presidents who became war criminals and are thus complicit in their crimes). His...
Kyle Reacts To Osama Bin Laden TikToks | The Kyle Kulinski Show
27 min · Semi-faux-viral story turns into viral story about the story, which turns into political lesson for the world we live in.
Trending Videos
Gaza Fights For Freedom | Directed by Abby Martin (2019)
84 min - This debut feature film by journalist Abby Martin began while reporting in Palestine, where she was denied entry into Gaza by the Israeli government on the accusation she was a “propagandist.” So...
Schooling the World (2010)
66 min - If you wanted to change an ancient culture in a generation, how would you do it? You would change the way it educates its children. The U.S. Government knew this in the 19th century when it...
Sure, Hamas are Nazis
21 min - "Comparing a state or people with Nazi Germany has a powerful and compelling effect on many people. It achieves the goal of dehumanizing an entire civilian population." Go to...
I Watched The Hamas Massacre Film. Here's My Thoughts. | Owen Jones
26 min - I was invited to watch a screening - organised by the IDF - of the Hamas atrocities committed on 7th October. Here's my response in detail. "When you learn of the horrors which humans are...
How Wolves Change Rivers | George Monbiot
4 min - When wolves were reintroduced to Yellowstone National Park in the United States after being absent nearly 70 years, the most remarkable "trophic cascade" occurred. What is a trophic cascade and...
Lowkey Exposes Stuart Seldowitz
6 min - Lowkey uncovers the powerful past of New York’s most famous racist ranter Join the Future of Journalism: 
We Exposed The Defense Industry's Biggest Lie
15 min - Politicians and corporate execs want to convince us that war creates jobs and economic stimulus for all. In reality, defense spending has become yet another way for wealth to transfer from the...
HyperNormalisation (2016)
161 min - We live in a time of great uncertainty and confusion. Events keep happening that seem inexplicable and out of control. Donald Trump, Brexit, the War in Syria, the endless migrant crisis, random...
Trending Articles
Documentaries about Living the Change
The Big Picture
10 Films That Will Metaphorically Blow Your Mind

Donate to Support Films For Action 

For $5 a month, you'll gain access to over 50 of our favorite world-changing documentaries while keeping us ad-free and financially independent.

Subscribe here | Explore the films

Your support helps grow our 5000+ video library, which is 99% free thanks to our patrons!


We're a People-Powered Library 

Sign up to add a documentary or video to our library and we'll help promote it. Half of our best content was added by members. Submissions just need to be embeddable (like from Youtube or Vimeo), and related to changing the world. 

We'd love you to become a regular contributor! Cheers,
The Films For Action team