Oct 12, 2023

Murder and Hostage-Taking Will Not Bring Peace or Justice, and Neither Will Apartheid

The one change will be that hardliners on all sides will have gained support—with no lessons learned—thus sowing the seeds for another round of violence.
By Dr. James J. Zogby / commondreams.org
Murder and Hostage-Taking Will Not Bring Peace or Justice, and Neither Will Apartheid
Members of Israeli security forces carry an injured person on a stretcher following a rocket attack from the Gaza. Palestinian militants in Gaza unexpectedly fired dozens of rockets at Israeli targets early on Saturday, the Israeli army said. (Photo by Ilia Yefimovich/picture alliance via Getty Images)

It has been horrifying to watch this most recent iteration of wanton violence in the Israeli-Palestinian arena. But it should not have been unexpected. What can also now be expected is that the horrific murders carried out by Hamas on day one will be more than matched by Israel as it proceeds to use its massive military power to massacre thousands of captive Palestinians trapped in the Gaza Strip.

What is also par for the course is that the U.S., instead of playing the role of the adult in the room, has once again reduced itself to being a cheerleader and coat-holder for one side, enabling and supporting Israel’s escalation of violence. In this regard, it was shocking to note that the State Department deleted two of its initial statements calling for restraint and protection of civilians, changing them to statements offering Israel our full support.

It’s distressing to see this nightmare unfolding precisely because we’ve been down this same road so many times before and, by now, should know exactly where it leads. It takes us back to where we began.

After the dust has settled and the tears have dried, other than having thousands of dead to mourn and bury, we’ll be right back to where we were when it started. The one change will be that hardliners on all sides will have gained support—with no lessons learned—thus sowing the seeds for another round of violence, at some indeterminate point in the future.

The lessons we should have learned are many. To begin with: just as violence will not end the occupation, neither will violence end the resistance to the occupation. Suicide bombers or Hamas rockets didn’t bring peace, they only hardened Israeli attitudes against Palestinians and peace. And Israel’s violent occupation, massive retaliations, its strangulation of Gaza, and its brutal repression of the Palestinians in the occupied West Bank and East Jerusalem hasn’t squashed the Palestinian will to be free. It has only fueled more resistance.

Occupation and oppression are cruel and inhumane—and the consequences of occupation can not be ignored. As a corollary of this, efforts by the US and Israeli leaders, going back to Shimon Peres, to build a New Middle East while failing to resolve the injustices of the Old Middle East are doomed. Herein lies a critical failure of this and past US Administrations.

Instead of seeing the possibility that the Abrahamic Accords could provide the US leverage to alter Israel’s behavior, the administration ignored the extremist policies and practices of the Netanyahu government by offering it more unearned benefits, further imperiling the prospects for Palestinian rights and regional peace. While the Israelis doubled down on apartheid, expanded settlements increasing the de facto annexation of the West Bank, conducted nightly undercover raids into Palestinian cities, allowed settlers to conduct violent raids into Palestinian areas, and accelerated provocative assaults into Jerusalem’s holiest sites —the US either acquiesced or made do with expressions of “concern.” At the same time, we rewarded Israel with admission into the US Visa Waiver Program - despite Israel’s failure to meet the program’s statutory requirements - and issued frequent pronouncements of “unwavering, unbreakable, unshakable” support.

The results of this US failure are clear. Hardliners in Israel have been emboldened to behave like a spoiled child knowing that there are no restraints on their behaviors. They therefore act with impunity. Meanwhile, Palestinians believing that there is no recognition of their humanity or their rights to freedom and security have come to feel like the abused child. They therefore feel no hesitation to strike out wildly to make their point.

The bottom line is that it was, to be sure, unpredictable that Hamas would engineer a surprise invasion of Israel, accompanied by the killing of hundreds of innocents and taking hundreds more hostage. But Israel should have known, and was warned, that the Palestinian pressure cooker was bound to explode. At the same time, Hamas should have known that Israel would respond with massive force that would result in the devastation of Gaza and the killing of thousands of innocent Palestinians. And they should have known that the US would do nothing to restrain Israel’s massive and deadly assaults.

While all parties share some degree of blame, I mainly fault successive US administrations for failing to play its self-proclaimed role of the promoter of human rights and peace. It has abdicated its responsibility diminishing itself to become Israel’s partner in the oppression of Palestinians. For shame.


Dr. James J. Zogby is the author of Arab Voices (2010) and the founder and president of the Arab American Institute (AAI), a Washington, D.C.-based organization which serves as the political and policy research arm of the Arab American community. Since 1985, Dr. Zogby and AAI have led Arab American efforts to secure political empowerment in the U.S. Through voter registration, education and mobilization, AAI has moved Arab Americans into the political mainstream. Dr. Zogby has also been personally active in U.S. politics for many years; in 1984 and 1988 he served as Deputy Campaign manager and Senior Advisor to the Jesse Jackson Presidential campaign. In 1988, he led the first ever debate on Palestinian statehood at that year's Democratic convention in Atlanta, GA. In 2000, 2008, and 2016 he served as an advisor to the Gore, Obama, and Sanders presidential campaigns. Full Bio >

Rate this article 
Human Rights
Positive Alternatives to Business as Usual
New Documentaries
Trending Videos
The Lie That Made Food Conglomerates Rich...And Is Slowly Poisoning Us
14 min - Nestle, Kellogg’s, and other big food conglomerates have been funding a massive misinformation campaign to make you think their foods are healthy. Their goal is to get you addicted, and make...
In The Eye Of The Storm: The Political Odyssey Of Yanis Varoufakis (2024)
258 min - 'In the Eye of the Storm' is a six-part documentary series about the dramatic journey and inspiring vision of one of the foremost political figures of our age, the maverick Greek economist Yanis...
Plutocracy: Political Repression In The U.S.A. (2019)
560 min - Plutocracy, by filmmaker Scott Noble, is the first documentary series to comprehensively examine early American history through the lens of class. Support the filmmaker's next film with a monthly...
Trending Articles
Deep Reads - Get Cozy and Dig in
Films That Inspire Inner Change
Subscribe for $5/mo to Watch over 50 Patron-Exclusive Films


Become a Patron. Support Films For Action.

For $5 a month, you'll gain access to over 50 patron-exclusive documentaries while keeping us ad-free and financially independent. We need 350 more Patrons to grow our team in 2024.

Subscribe here

Our 6000+ video library is 99% free, ad-free, and entirely community-funded thanks to our patrons!