Dec 9, 2025

People Aren’t Being “Replaced” — They’re Being Distracted From Who Actually Robbed Them

“Invasion” and “replacement” narratives function as cover stories for the corporate plunder of the working class, turning justified anger away from elites and toward scapegoats.
By Tim Hjersted / filmsforaction.org

If you begin from the premise that every human being is fundamentally the same species with the same capacities, needs, and rights, then a chart like this doesn’t signal danger — it signals nothing more than the ordinary movement of people across the Earth.

“Race” is not a biological category but a political invention, historically constructed to justify hierarchy, domination, and exploitation. Today it serves mainly as a crude, superficial shorthand for complex patterns of human geographic variation.

Once you understand that, demographic graphs lose their emotional charge. They become a record of migration, interconnection, and the constant mixing that has defined human history since the beginning.

The anxiety this graph provokes in some circles — particularly the MAGA movement — has very little to do with demographics themselves and everything to do with power.

For decades, the U.S. economy has been reorganized around neoliberal policies that shipped jobs overseas, crushed unions, privatized public goods, and turned working life into a permanent state of insecurity.

Both major US parties are responsible for this.

What MAGA voters are actually angry about is that betrayal — stagnant wages, disappearing communities, rigged markets, and political systems that answer to money instead of people. But instead of that anger being directed upward at the corporate and political elites who engineered this collapse, it is deliberately redirected downward at immigrants and cultural scapegoats.

The language of “invasion” and “replacement” isn’t an organic response to demographic change — it’s a manufactured narrative designed to keep a divided working class punching sideways while the real authors of economic devastation continue looting the country undisturbed.

Migration is not an existential threat. It is humanity's oldest survival mechanism, and a timeless response to hardship, war, and the pursuit of opportunity.

What threatens societies is not diversity but inequality — the deliberate policies that pit workers against one another, weaponize fear, and obscure the real distribution of wealth and power.

If people directed even a fraction of the energy spent worrying about demographic change toward challenging the structures that impoverish them, we might actually begin addressing the crises that affect everyone, regardless of ancestry.

Human beings move. Populations change. The tragedy is not that the country is becoming more diverse. The tragedy is that many are being taught to see that diversity as danger rather than as a reminder of our shared humanity and our shared struggle against systems that exploit us all.


Tim Hjersted is the director and co-founder of Films For Action, a library dedicated to the people and movements creating a more free, regenerative and democratic society.

Subscribe on Substack for updates. You can contact the author here.

This work is licensed under an Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License
Economics   Media Literacy   Politics   Social Issues
Economics
The Economics of Happiness
Patron Documentaries
Subscribe for $5/mo to watch over 50 patron-exclusive films
Trending Videos Explore All
Trending Articles Explore All
Rediscovering Our Sacred Wholeness
Our mission is to support the people and movements creating a more free, regenerative and democratic society. 



Subscribe for $5/mo to support us and watch over 50 patron-exclusive documentaries.

Share this: