1968: a Missed Chance for Socialism

Precisely 50 years ago, the international anti-imperialistic students’ movement culminated in the uprisings in France. At that time, Dieter Duhm, a psychoanalyst and sociologist, was a spokesman of the “new left” in the German students’ movement and coined the slogan, “Revolution without emancipation is counterrevolution.” He deepened the idea of merging the political revolution on the outer with a liberation from the structures of fear in the inner in his best-selling book Angst im Kapitalismus [Fear in Capitalism] in 1972. Ultimately, this exploration brought him to initiate a radical social experiment that evolved into the Tamera Peace Research & Education Center in Portugal in 1995.
By Dr. Dieter Duhm / tikkun.org
Jul 23, 2018
1968: a Missed Chance for Socialism

The radical critique of capitalism requires the concept of a comprehensive alternative. What are the structures of post-capitalist society? Is there a realistic blueprint for planetary peace? We are at a historic point when the lives of countless fellow beings on our planet rely on genuine answers to these questions.

The German student movement of the last century was part of an international struggle against imperialist power and authoritarian structures. The movement reached its peak 50 years ago. At that time, I was a student leader in the area of Mannheim-Ludwigshafen. I loved the anti-authoritarian revolt, the solidarity on the streets, the hospitality among the comrades in all cities, and the common struggle against the barbarism of the existing society. Yet I wondered, did the comrades really believe in the things they were saying, such as, “All power in the state to the proletariat!” and similar slogans? We knew what we opposed but didn’t actually have a positive aim. It was a pure anti-movement, carried by a kind of anger that would soon begin to rage mercilessly among the various left-wing factions too. I realized that this fight could never succeed, given the psychological structures of people within the leftist groups.

Genuine socialism needs a social basis. It isn’t enough to propagate it ideologically and politically without knowing the interpersonal foundations that make it possible in the first place. How do we deal with conflicts around sexuality, love and jealousy, with latent rivalries, competitive struggles etc.? As far as I know, almost all socialist movements up until now have failed due to such conflicts among people. The horror around us that we wanted to fight through political strategies also existed inside our groups. The original solidarity among us was replaced by ideological struggles, fights over leadership and intellectual authority, mutual slander and open hatred. After the first protesters had taken to the streets with Stalin posters and the original movement had begun to break into the many so-called “K groups,” I sensed the brutal infantilism of these events. The violence they wanted to fight on the outside also lived inside themselves. Thus, the movement was doomed to disintegrate from the inside out.

Socialism points to the idea of a humane and just society. The left failed because of the contradiction between this goal and the behavior that emerged in trying to attain it. The socialist or communist structures which were to be built externally – e.g. structures of communality, justice, equality and solidarity – didn’t yet exist within the people who were trying to build them. What was missing was a vision that had the power to overcome the very ordinary human conflicts around competition, envy and jealousy. It was no longer about humane goals, but – psychologically speaking – the ideological compensation of unresolved psychological problems around love, anxiety and power. I stepped out of the leftist movement and went off for some years of learning and wandering, visiting other places working on cultural metamorphosis. For me, it was about creating a sustainable social, spiritual and ethical basis for the political idea.

In 1968, Rudi Dutschke spoke of the “necessity of a long-lasting cultural revolution, particularly in the highly developed capitalist countries of central Europe, as a condition for the possibility of revolutionizing all of society.” Four years earlier, he wrote in his diary that Jesus Christ was “the world’s greatest revolutionary.” These astounding statements, that seem to anticipate new ideas, have to be taken up and deepened today if we want to establish a worldwide movement for true liberation.

To be able to reorient society toward a humane direction we needed a completely different concept, which involved the inner transformation of the comrades. This is why I wrote the much-read “Mannheim paper” and the booklet “Revolution without emancipation is counterrevolution” at the time. I have continued working on these thoughts to this day. They led to the global “Healing Biotopes Plan” and the vision of a new civilization on Earth: “Terra Nova.” Over the course of our 40 years of community experience, we came to see some truths that I believe are fundamental to any humane movement.

There will be no peace on Earth as long as there is war within us, for example in our love relationships. We can only achieve as much peace on the outside as we have realized inside ourselves. That’s why beginning to see a vision for sustainable peace is key for any peacework. We are set a challenge: to take the images of our true yearnings that are latent in our souls seriously and turn them into effective icons. These include soul images from the areas of love, sexuality, community and religion, images of a new ethic for dealing with each other, for worldwide cooperation with other groups, for our coexistence with the animal world and finally for the realization of our own purpose and entelechy. The project that has arisen around the “Healing Biotopes Plan” works on creating a worldwide network of people and groups who are developing new answers both to the global situation of the Earth and to their own life situations. We currently work with groups around the world, such as the Peace Community of San José de Apartadó in Colombia, Standing Rock in the United States, the permaculture center of Tiyeda and Séda Abalah in Togo and many others. Working in crisis areas, these projects collaborate to find a common global direction. In this way a global movement is slowly arising that follows the motto “Defend the Sacred,” coined by the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe, and the overall vision of “Terra Nova.”

At the same time as the German and international student movements rose up, completely different approaches for reorienting human society emerged around the world. Large communities based on ecological and spiritual approaches came into being, such as the spiritual community of Auroville in India, which also celebrated its 50th anniversary this year, the sannyasins in Poona and the well-known spiritual communities of Findhorn (Scotland) and Damanhur (Italy). Last but not least, there was also the Austrian “Friedrichshof,” which briefly came into being after the first wave of revolutionary fervor and tried to deal with the topic of sexuality in their own – one-sided – way. Could all these varied movements contain relevant contributions to a well-founded renewal of human society? Viewed retrospectively from a distance, we can see a multitude of initiatives and movements that tried to liberate human life from the clutches of the capitalist world and bring us closer to a future worth living. It seemed almost accidental which of these movements one personally belonged to. However, there was still no common foundation and no common goal uniting these groups.

Many pioneering impulses entered the orbit at this time, many things needed to be seen and considered in order to develop a realistic overall vision for our situation as humanity. So, in the fall of 1976, I first retreated to a farm in Lower Bavaria for half a year to reflect on everything and find a meaningful way out of the ideological scrub.

Developing as a result of the path that started back then, we eventually founded Tamera in Portugal, a peace school and holistic life model with currently about 170 co-workers and a growing international network. We’re no longer working only on building a local community, but on the worldwide foundations of a new humane civilization.

Trending Videos
Culture In Decline
Can You See It?
Anti-Fascist Activism & The Value of Nonviolence
Featured Films

Films For Action hosts a mini-subscription service that currently offers 36 highly-curated films to Patron subscribers donating $5 per month.

Subscribe here. Your support helps grow our library, which is 99% free.


How to Use this Library

  • Use the Explore button to filter content by type and topic. Selections stack, so you can view Film Types about Specific Topics.

  • You're encouraged to submit videos directly to our library. Just click +Add Video at the top of the site and paste the video URL to get started. We share our favorite submissions with our fans on social media and feature them more prominently on the site.

  • Want to support us and watch some great films in the process? Our $5/mo Patrons get access to a growing number of our favorite documentaries that are unavailable for free.

  • Filmmakers: Interested in our TVOD or SVOD services? Contact us.

  • If you have a site or film suggestion, want to help out, or you're a filmmaker looking to collaborate, drop us a line via our contact page. Let's be the media!