What Happens When Silicon Valley Experiments With Direct Democracy
What Happens When Silicon Valley Experiments With Direct Democracy
By Gregory Fernenstein / fastcoexist.com
Jul 18, 2014

Like a few other cities, the city is letting some citizens vote directly on how the city spends its money. But, of course, it's adding an online twist.
 

The heart of Silicon Valley is experimenting with a novel form of direct democracy that gives citizens direct control over the city's budget. Unlike most cities, where budgets are divvied up in closed door meetings, three of San Francisco's neighborhoods are convening local residents to decide how roughly $300,000 of their tax money will be spent. Through intensive collaboration at town halls, officials will whittle­ down the best ideas into a list of proposals that will be voted on later this year.

Though so­-called "participatory budgeting" has been tried before, San Francisco plans (of course) on adding a digital twist and allowing citizens to vote for the projects online, in what could be one of the only instances of digital direct democracy in American history.

"What's unique here, is that there's a certain level of transparency that doesn't exist in the previous system," explains City Supervisor Malia Cohen, who says she decided to jump on the participatory bandwagon after seeing impressive results from last year's experiment. "They are at the table when these votes are going down," she says.

"Typically budgets are determined in back rooms by politicians sitting around trying to figure out how to spend the people's money," Supervisor David Chiu said, at the announcement of the online participatory budgeting program, last fall.

For instance, last year, residents from Supervisor Chiu's neighborhoods found ways to increase funding to eviction-­threatened residents, and provide summer jobs cleaning up graffiti. The "project provided a solution to address the dual needs advocated by young people for jobs and neighborhood residents for graffiti removal," explains Chiu's legislative, aid, Amy Chan.

To be sure, it's not entirely a bottom­-up process. The amount of money for each neighborhood is chosen by state agencies and is taken out of funds ordinarily allocated to the budget. Each representative has to believe that the people are better at allocating this particular pot of money. Additionally, the decisions still have to be logically possible and legal. Budget officers attend the meetings to see how suggestions might have to be tweaked or ditched, depending on existing laws.

Research finds that participatory budgeting could help alleviate some of San Francisco's notorious inequality. On average, researchers find, participatory budgeting distributes funds more equitably, especially to issues concerning the most needy residents. In Brazil, the birthplace of participatory budgeting, researchers found that citizen's decisions actually reduced infant mortality rates. It turns out that mothers have a much better idea of what their children need than distant bureaucrats.

During one of San Francisco's town halls, most of the proposals I witness were about improving everyday pains: better bus stops, improved parking, and sidewalks repairs. The more ambitious projects proposed new farmer's markets and graffiti­-clean-up summer jobs for idle youth.

"It's a great way for politicians to really find out what the people want. Politicians, they think they know what people want," said Chris Waddling, who runs a local news blog for San Francisco's District 10. "Something like this, where you're brainstorming, you can really come up with ideas maybe someone hasn't thought of."

City officials are still mulling over how to give the budgeting process a digital upgrade. In Brazil, the origin country of participatory budgeting, officials gather ideas from a crowdsourcing utility called wiki­surveys, which ranks ideas through a series of pair­wise questions and the option to offer a third option in a text box.

Princeton University even developed a user­-friendly version of wiki­surveys called All Our Ideas.

There's demonstrated ways that tech can benefit the direct democratic process. Tiago Peixoto, a World Bank consultant and leading expert in participatory democracy, found that women tend to participate slightly more online than men, which is the reverse for offline participation (49% offline vs. 55% online).

Additionally, in Brazil, SMS alerts have been able bring in social classes that otherwise may have been excluded from the process. "Specific outreach efforts ensure the participation of the least privileged sectors of society," Peixoto writes to me.

This is an on­going process. Soon we'll be able to see the results soon enough of their experiment in radical direct democracy.

 



GREGORY FERENSTEIN

I am a writer and an educator. As a writer, I investigate how technology is shaping education, politics, Generation Y, social good, and the media industry. As an educator, I design communication curricula for college students. Email me at greg [at]] gregferenstein .[dot]] com

4.0 ·
1
Trending Today
How a Lack of Touch Is Destroying Men
Mark Green · 5,596 views today · Why Men Need More Platonic Touch in their Lives
Globalization Makes No Sense
Chris Agnos · 3,124 views today · When I lived in San Francisco, I often would marvel at the movement of goods through the ports across the bay in Oakland. Full container ships would enter the bay one after...
Proof of Evolution That You Can Find on Your Body
4 min · 2,136 views today · Vestigial structures are evolution's leftovers — body parts that, through inheritance, have outlived the context in which they arose. Some of the most delightful reminders of...
Immigrants For Sale (2015)
33 min · 2,064 views today · The detention of migrants has become a multi-billion dollar industry in which immigrants are sold to the highest bidder and traded like mere products. The Corrections...
How Comedy Can Disarm Bullies
3 min · 1,954 views today · As long as you're funny, it can get you out of almost anything - even getting mugged, as co-founder of Between Two Ferns Scott Aukerman recounts. Unfortunately, not everyone...
Your Lifestyle Has Already Been Designed (The Real Reason For The Forty-Hour Workweek)
David Cain · 1,468 views today · Well I’m in the working world again. I’ve found myself a well-paying gig in the engineering industry, and life finally feels like it’s returning to normal after my nine months...
Those That Did Not Seek Revenge
Dr. Ann Russo · 1,219 views today · Dr. Ann Russo on violence, healing, and transforming justice.
DAPL Opponents Vow to 'Rise' From Ashes of Oceti Sakowin and Keep Fighting
Lauren McCauley · 1,056 views today · 'They cannot extinguish the fire that Standing Rock started,' Dallas Goldtooth declared
Compassion, the Antidote
Martin Doblmeier · 994 views today · Thich Nhat Hanh has published nearly 100 books and is one of the best-known teachers of Zen Buddhism in the world today. In the early 1960s his practice of what he termed...
A Hauntingly Beautiful Short Film About Life and Death
5 min · 971 views today · The Life of Death is a touching handdrawn animation about the day Death fell in love with Life.
John Lennon's "Imagine," Made Into a Comic Strip
John Lennon. Art by Pablo Stanley · 970 views today · This is easily the best comic strip ever made.  Pabl
Without Saying a Word This 6 Minute Clip From Samsara Will Make You Speechless
6 min · 869 views today · Can you put this video into words? It's a clip from the phenomenal documentary Samsara, directed by Ron Fricke, who also made Baraka.  If you're interested in watching...
Today I Rise: This Beautiful Short Film Is Like a Love Poem For Your Heart and Soul
4 min · 800 views today · "The world is missing what I am ready to give: My Wisdom, My Sweetness, My Love and My hunger for Peace." "Where are you? Where are you, little girl with broken wings but full...
Stunning Small Homes Form Part of a Communal Compound for Best Friends
Lighter Side · 786 views today · If you’re lucky enough to have longtime friends even as an adult, then you know probably already know how much it means to be able to spend time together. Maybe you even have a...
How Wolves Change Rivers
4 min · 674 views today · When wolves were reintroduced to Yellowstone National Park in the United States after being absent nearly 70 years, the most remarkable "trophic cascade" occurred. What is a...
The Foiled Bomb Plot in Kansas That Didn't Make Trump's Terror List
5 min · 650 views today · When a plot by a pro-white militia to bomb a Somali mosque in Kansas was foiled by the FBI last October, the aborted conspiracy received little national coverage - nor did it...
Where the Term "Redneck" Came From
15 min · 594 views today · If you don't know this story, you'll never look at the word the same again.  This is just a window into the sometimes shocking, subversive and untold history of the United...
Touch Isolation: How Homophobia Has Robbed All Men Of Touch
Mark Greene · 594 views today · Homophobic prohibitions against male touch are hurting straight men as well.
10 Words Every Girl Should Learn
Soraya Chemaly · 378 views today · "Stop interrupting me."  "I just said that." "No explanation needed." In fifth grade, I won the school courtesy prize. In other words, I won an award for being polite. My...
The Most Astounding Fact about the Universe
3 min · 243 views today · This is Neil Degrasse Tyson's response when asked to describe the most astounding fact about the universe. Background music is the cinematic orchestra - To build a home.
Load More
What's Next
Like us on Facebook?
What Happens When Silicon Valley Experiments With Direct Democracy