San Diego, CA - Events Local News Contact
San Diego City Council: Stop Curfew Sweeps in San Diego, California
By Cathy Mendonca, Aaron Leaf / change.org

What are curfew sweeps?
Curfew sweeps are organized deployments of teams of officers to arrest youth under the age of 18 on the street during curfew hours between 10 pm and 6am. Youth are taken to a make shift detention center at Cherokee Point Elementary School and parents are called to pick them up.

Curfews sweeps criminalize innocent low income youth
Regrettably to date, thousands of innocent youth have been arrested and detained, forced to pay large fees or attend a diversion program, for a fee. The overwhelming majority of youth were committing no crime at the time of their arrest. For most, this is their first contact with any type of law enforcement and for many the experience has a lasting negative effect.

Curfew sweeps do not keep youth safe nor do they reduce juvenile crime
There is no support for the hypothesis that jurisdictions with curfews experience lower crime levels, accelerated youth crime reduction, or lower rates of juvenile violent death than jurisdictions without curfews. In Houston, a curfew was introduced, and youth crime went down by 22%. But in New York, where no curfew exists, youth crime went down 30%. In Detroit and New Orleans, youth crime increased after curfews were introduced. And in San Francisco, youth crime went down after a curfew was repealed.

Curfew sweeps racially discriminate
These sweeps disproportionately target youth of color, and further contribute to pushing them into the prison systems. In San Diego, Latino and black youth make up 74% of the juvenile population in juvenile facilities. In San Diego, curfew sweeps are held bimonthly in City Heights and other communities of color in southeast San Diego compared to infrequent or nonexistent sweeps in other areas of the city. Mira Mesa for example has a higher crime rate than City Heights however there are no regular sweeps there.

Curfew sweeps usurp the rights of parents
The United States Supreme Court has repeatedly recognized that curfew sweeps violate rights of parents to direct the upbringing of their children. They ruled that these were “fundamental” parental rights. in past California curfew law cases the Court of Appeals ruled “ The child is not the mere creature of the state; those who nurture [them] and direct [their] destiny have the right and the high duty, to recognize and prepare [them] for additional obligations.”

Curfew sweeps are unconstitutional
Curfew measures violate the 1st, 4th, 9th, and 14th amendment constitutional rights of children and parents.In 1997, in a federal case addressing the issue of curfews, Nunez v. San Diego, 114 F.3d 935, 949 (9th Cir. 1997), the Court of Appeals ruled that a juvenile curfew ordinance violated the fundamental right of minors to move about freely. In the case of a D.C. curfew Act, U.S. District Court Judge Emmet G. Sullivan ruled curfews to be “flatly unconstitutional”.In the case of a D.C. curfew Act, U.S. District Court Judge Emmet G. Sullivan ruled curfews to be “flatly unconstitutional”

According to the National Council on Crime and Delinquency (NCCD), curfew enforcement is often ineffective and unnecessarily funnels large numbers of non delinquent youth into a criminal justice system that is already inundated with alleged offenders. In addition, some opponents cite a lack of evidence supporting the efficacy of curfew legislation. According to the literature review conducted by Ruefle and Reynolds, little or no recent evidence indicates that curfew initiatives have an effect on juvenile crime, nor has research addressed the impact of curfews and their enforcement on the criminal justice system as a whole.

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), argues that curfew measures violate the constitutional rights of children and parents. Legal challenges to the constitutionality of curfew laws are most often based on the 1st, 4th, 9th, and 14th amendments to the U.S. Constitution, according to a recent report by OJJDP. Opponents of curfew ordinances are concerned with the restrictive nature of these laws and the limitations on a youth's first amendment right to free speech and association. Others argue that curfews give law enforcement excessive power to detain children without probable cause and subject them to police questioning in violation of the fourth amendment's guarantees against unreasonable search and seizure. Additional legal challenges to curfew laws have been based on the ninth amendment, which has been interpreted as providing a privacy right applicable to parents rearing children. Yet other critics argue that curfews violate the equal protection clause of the 14th amendment by establishing a suspect classification based solely on the age of a group of individuals.Some groups, like NCCD, fear that this classification may result in a disparate enforcement of curfew initiatives, to the detriment of minority youth. Further, some court cases have struck down curfew laws because they are vague and overreaching, not because they violate fundamental rights.
http://www.ojjdp.gov/pubs/reform/ch2_c.html

 

Load Comments
You Might Be Interested In
5 min · If you've ever seen footage taken inside industrial farms, you know it isn't pretty. In fact, it's so ugly that it's against the law in some states to even look. - Silveira Carolyn Read more about this story here.
72 min · Wolf's impassioned arguments prove totally compelling, and the filmmakers' accompanying illustrations transport her comparisons from the abstract to the historic- VARIETYExpertly crafted by award-winning filmmakers Annie Sundberg and Ricki Stern (The Devil Came on Horseback...
30 min · This 30-minute documentary focuses on Permaculture and Organic Farming in South Africa and what it can do to transform society at a grass roots level, to create sustainable lives for individuals, communities and South Africa as a whole. The documentary aims to educate the...
82 min · This Scandinavian production draws on some of the observational strategies of Godfrey Reggio's Koyaanisqatsi, allowing us to reflect on patterns and phenomena of human and natural existence from both intimate and sweeping viewpoints.
80 min · Join gonzo journalist Brendon (aka Skull Babylon) as he sets off on a journey to reunite with long lost new found friends and spirit family at the Three Days of Light consciousness festival and retreat. Synopsis: Through this story we see first hand accounts of the youth and...
1 min · "The Runner - Challenge Homophobia In Sport" is a short video made by  25 young people, who participated in the study session "Youth Sport speaks out on TabooPhobia" during this year's "Eurogames" in Budapets, with the end product a youth socialmedia campaign to challenge...
2 min · Can you define eco-terrorism? In December 2005, Daniel McGowan was arrested by Federal agents in a nationwide sweep of radical environmentalists involved with the Earth Liberation Front-- a group the FBI has called America's "number one domestic terrorism threat." For years...
7 min · Based on three actual stories told by young people in New Mexico after participating in a survey on youth health access, this video recreates what it can be like for young people to access health services and information. Running Time: 6.5 minutes     Christian Redbird...
79 min · #ReGENERATION explores the inherent cynicism found in many of today's youth and young adults, and the influences that perpetuate our culture's apathetic approach to social and political causes. The film features three intersecting stories of students, parents, and artists all...
2 min · Host your own screening @ http://tugg.com/regeneration. The latest trailer for the award-winning documentary film that explores the galvanizing forces behind the Occupy Movement and the state of social activism among today's youth.
5 min · This is a story of about 20 families who have purposefully uprooted from out of their comfortable suburban homes and moved into one of the worst neighborhoods in Kansas City.  They bought homes within a 5 block radius of each other and put down a stake for the sake of the...
10 min · Immigrants are for sale in this country. Sold to private prison corporations who are locking them up for obscene profits!Here are the top 3 things YOU need to know about the Private Prison money scheme:The victims: Private prisons don't care about who they lock up. At a rate...
Charles Eisenstein · The economic and legal system rewards corporations that bulldoze, stripmine and burn. A new law against ecocide could halt this destruction. Designer Vivienne Westwood expressed anguish and alarm at the worsening state of the planet, at a press conference yesterday. "The...
Anthony Gregory · I suppose it takes a true radical these days to question the progressive’s sacred cow: Ronald Reagan. You read that right. This paradigm of modern conservatism was one of the most important American champions of gun control in recent decades, and so he has become a...
Amy Goodman · Amidst the White House and congressional theatrics surrounding the so-called fiscal-cliff negotiations, a number of bills were signed into law by President Barack Obama that renew some of the worst excesses of the Bush years. Largely ignored by the media, these laws further...
Nicholas Powers · CREATING COMMUNITY: (Above) Chris O’Donnell, 24, of Bushwick, Brooklyn, takes a break at the Occupy Wall Street encampment. The kitchen has been serving free meals to as many as 1,000 people a day. (Photo by Amelia Holowaty Krales)   “Who is ready to defend our park?” the...
Mike Adams · After years of sweeping the issue under the rug and hoping no one would notice, the FDA has now finally admitted that chicken meat sold in the USA contains arsenic, a cancer-causing toxic chemical that's fatal in high doses. But the real story is where this arsenic comes...
Chris Hedges · Attorneys Carl J. Mayer and Bruce I. Afran filed a complaint Friday in the Southern U.S. District Court in New York City on my behalf as a plaintiff against Barack Obama and Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta to challenge the legality of the Authorization for Use of Military...
Jose Ramos · Liquid Democracy is one of the boldest contemporary innovations in democratic decision-making. The idea uses web technology that allows users to interact in new ways. Its primary innovators are located in Berlin, and Germany has been the first to adopt and apply Liquid...
Kevin Carson · A note of clarification: The "left" in left libertarian in the title was added to distinguish the solutions this article presents from the right-learning associations most people have of American libertarianism. If you're only used to reading Ron Paul style libertarian...
Like us on Facebook?