How Your pension is Being Used in a $6 Trillion Climate Gamble
By Bill McKibben and Jeremy Leggett / guardian.co.uk
Apr 19, 2013

Suppose you weren’t worried that we humans are destroying our water supply and eroding our ability to feed ourselves by burning coal and gas and oil and hence changing climate. Suppose you thought that was all liberal hooey. What might worry you about fossil fuels instead? How about a six trillion dollar bet, including a big slug of your own money, on people not doing what they have said they are going to do, and that some have already sworn to do in law? 

Photo: The tailings pond at the Syncrude mine north of Fort McMurray, Alberta, Canada. Tar sands could become a 'stranded asset', campaigners say. (Credit: Ashley Cooper pics/Alamy)

Six trillion dollars is what oil, gas, and coal companies will invest over the next ten years on turning fossil fuel deposits into reserves, assuming last year’s level of investment stays the same. Reserves are by definition bodies of oil, gas or coal that can be drilled or mined economically. Regulators allow companies, currently, to book them as assets, and on the assumption that they are at zero risk of being stranded - left below ground, "value"unrealized - over the full life of their exploitation. Yet a report published today shows they are at very real risk of being stranded, and in large quantity. 

Governments agreed in 2010 to keep global warming below two degrees. The Carbon Tracker Initiative, a group of concerned financial analysts based in London, has teamed up with the Grantham Institute, a climate research centre, to calculate how much carbon it would take to reach that two degree threshold, and what it means for the capital markets. By this calculation, fully 60 to 80% of oil, gas and coal reserves listed on stock exchanges are unburnable. 

The six trillion dollar bet is that this calculation remains entirely theoretical, and that fossil-fuel companies will be allowed to keep pumping up the carbon bubble by investing more cash to turn resources into reserves, and continue booking them at full value, assuming zero risk of devaluation. It's a bet that effectively says to government: “nah, we don’t believe a word you say. We think you’ll do nothing about climate change for decades."

Yet the British government, for one, has signed its targets into law, and the Copenhagen Accord brokered by the Obama administration in 2009 specifically sets 2 degrees as its goal. And all governments at the most recent annual climate negotiations have agreed to set legally binding targets at the 2015 climate summit in Paris.

Both companies and ordinary citizens ought to be very worried by this disconnect between capital markets and climate policymaking. This is because so much of the value of stock exchanges involves pension money, and so much of peoples’ prosperity hinges on the value of their pensions. HSBC recently calculated that shares in coal companies could be devalued by 40-60% in a world acting on the climate threat.

Yet vast pension assets are invested in coal. The ratings agency Standard and Poor’s recently concluded that the business models of tar sands companies could be invalidated in a world acting to constrain carbon. Yet vast pension assets are invested in tar sands.

The six trillion dollar bet also involves two mandatory side bets. The first is that the news on climate change doesn’t get worse than it already is, so putting governments under even more pressure to act on carbon than they already are.

Sadly, we and many like us think it will, especially as natural amplifiers to global warming, like melting permafrost, kick in. For this reason we think that the Carbon Tracker Grantham figures are conservative: if they are wrong, they are much more likely to be wrong on the down side. 

The second side bet is that the new civil resistance to fossil fuels won’t add significantly to the pressure on governments to act. We think it will, for reasons you can see on the 350.org website, and in the rising tide of peaceful direct action on streets, in campuses, on solar rooftops, and elsewhere across society. 

The pooled message to regulators, from Carbon Tracker analysts and 350.org activists alike, is clear. Do your job. Start requiring recognition of stranded carbon-asset risk in capital-markets processes. Start deflating the carbon bubble before it pops. 

The message to all the players across the financial chain, from ratings agencies through accountants, to actuaries, investment advisors and all the rest, is also obvious. If the regulators won’t do their job, do it for them. Jump, before you are pushed.

Bill McKibben

Bill McKibben is Schumann Distinguished Scholar at Middlebury College and co-founder of 350.org. His most recent book is Eaarth: Making a Life on a Tough New Planet.

Jeremy Leggett

Jeremy Leggett is Chairman of Carbon Tracker. He is author of The Carbon War and Half Gone.

 

3.5 ·
1
Trending Today
Bertrand Russell & Buckminster Fuller on Why We Should Work Less, and Live & Learn More
Josh Jones17,923 views today ·
7 Signs of Tyranny
2 min12,021 views today ·
4.1 Miles
21 min6,658 views today ·
Forget Shorter Showers: Why Personal Change Does Not Equal Political Change (2015)
11 min5,504 views today ·
The Venus Project Plans to Bring Humanity to the Next Stage of Social Evolution. Here's How.
Daniel Araya with Roxanne Meadows5,320 views today ·
The Trump Report - The Real Fake News About The Dakota Access Pipeline
2 min4,978 views today ·
What It Takes to Change Hearts and Minds
Colin Beavan3,317 views today ·
The Choice Between Fear And Love
5 min2,899 views today ·
Why Would Any of Us Want to Live like a Savage?
Juan Pablo Quinonez2,737 views today ·
How Independent is Hollywood?
4 min2,352 views today ·
Touch Isolation: How Homophobia Has Robbed All Men Of Touch
Mark Greene1,430 views today ·
How a Lack of Touch Is Destroying Men
Mark Green1,259 views today ·
Load More
New
Chris Hedges & Abby Martin - Trump, Fascism & the Christian Right
26 min
4.1 Miles
21 min
7 Signs of Tyranny
2 min
How to Be a Great Listener
5 min
DAPL Opponents Vow to 'Rise' From Ashes of Oceti Sakowin and Keep Fighting
Lauren McCauley
Those That Did Not Seek Revenge
Dr. Ann Russo
MLK Stands With Standing Rock (#NoDAPL)
3 min
Michael Moore Wants to Help You Find Your Next Anti-Trump Protest
Sarah Ruiz-Grossman
Saramurillo, Justice for Peru's Amazonian Peoples?
9 min
Globalization Makes No Sense
Chris Agnos
From Sanctuary City to Liberated City
Frank Lara
The London Anarchist Group Squatting Mansions to Fight Homelessness
6 min
Load More
What's Next
Plan B: Mobilizing to Save Civilization (2011)
74 min
Bill McKibben - Why is 350 the most important number in the world?
11 min
Fossil Free by '33
27 min
Like us on Facebook?
How Your pension is Being Used in a $6 Trillion Climate Gamble