Indianapolis, IN - Events Local News Groups Contact
Smith: Indy Should Favor Gardeners in Clash over Urban farms
Smith: Indy Should Favor Gardeners in Clash over Urban farms
By Erika D. Smith / indystar.com
Jul 23, 2014

For the past 20 years, Kay Grimm has spent her days toiling on the Near Eastside, turning five empty lots in the shadow of the Indianapolis Re-entry Education Facility into a permaculture garden filled with exotic fruit, vegetables and livestock.

For 10 of those 20 years, Sue Spicer has helped her, tending to beehives and sheep that mow — translation, eat — the grass of another lot they own across the street.

To Kay and Sue and other gardeners, Fruit Loop Acres is a beautiful labor of love that should be allowed to grow. To others, it's an ugly mess, a tangle of untamed greenery interspersed with smelly animals, that should be shut down.

Who is right? It's hard to say, and the city's laws are largely silent.

Indianapolis hasn't updated its zoning code since the 1970s, but in that time, a cottage industry of urban homesteading has taken root. Agriculture is no longer just about large farms in rural areas. People own goats in Broad Ripple. They have chicken coops in their backyards in Downtown. Residents in the core of the city are finding safe ways to plant fruit trees and grow vegetables on contaminated lots.

It's a good trend, a healthy trend. One that can go a long way toward addressing the shortage of fresh produce in urban food deserts. And one that Mayor Greg Ballard's administration has been right to encourage by donating empty lots to neighborhood groups and nonprofits interested in starting community gardens.

But regulating urban homesteading is another matter entirely.

The plan is to wait until the city finishes overhauling its zoning code — a process that could take until next year. There will, for the first time, be a section covering "urban agriculture."

The problem is people have been making up their own rules for a long time, relying on parts of the zoning code that seem applicable and filling in the blanks when there's no guidance.

The results have been uneven.

The city, for example, cited Grimm and Spicer for having high weeds and grass on one of their lots while one sheep was grazing on it.

"We didn't argue," Spicer said of the citation. "We just mowed."

Weeks later, a neighbor reported the permaculture garden for high weeds and grass. After a lengthy inspection, city officials decided it was up to code.

That is one clash of many. Others are over the proposed zoning language itself. On Wednesday, homesteaders took city officials to task at two public meetings at the Indiana State Fairgrounds.

On the livestock restrictions, they balked at rules that set a specific ratio of chickens to roosters, as well as limit the size and number of animals that residents can own. They wanted to know if goats and chickens could be grandfathered in if they owned more than the required number. And they talked about the potential for disease if they could no longer rotate male and female animals in and out of their livestock population.

On the urban gardening side, they complained about restrictions on when and how people can sell produce to neighbors.

What came through most is that the urban homesteaders know what it takes to be successful at urban agriculture in Indianapolis, and city officials need to listen them and make changes before moving forward with the new code.

What's most important is that we don't deter people from being homesteaders.

At a time when people in the urban core regularly steal food from gardens and eggs from chicken coops because they don't have enough to eat, we need to encourage people to come up with creative solutions to our food-desert crisis. We need more upstart farmer's markets and more residents working together to solve the problems of their neighborhoods.

Zoning is a tricky thing, but we must strive for a balance. And if we can't quite achieve that, we should err on the side of the code being too loose rather than too restrictive.

4.0 ·
1
Trending Today
How Seattle Voted to Tax the Rich
Adam Ziemkowski and Rebekah Liebermann4,072 views today ·
What Makes Call-Out Culture So Toxic
Asam Ahmad2,697 views today ·
87 Deeply Subversive Documentaries That Challenge the Status Quo
Films For Action2,449 views today ·
When We Judge a Person Harshly With a Label or Dismissal, We Kill the Human Being Inside of Them
Tim Hjersted1,301 views today ·
John Lennon's "Imagine," Made Into a Comic Strip
John Lennon. Art by Pablo Stanley1,224 views today ·
On the Wildness of Children: The Revolution Will Not Take Place In The Classroom
Carol Black1,106 views today ·
Joanna Macy on How to Prepare Internally for WHATEVER Comes Next
Joanna Macy1,100 views today ·
Pentagon Study Declares American Empire Is ‘Collapsing’
Nafeez Ahmed1,021 views today ·
Was The Soviet Union Really a Socialist Country? Noam Chomsky Dispels This Propaganda In 1 Minute
1 min987 views today ·
Load More
What's Next
Bill Mollison: The Global Gardener - Permaculture in 4 Different Climatic Zones (1991)
120 min
Urban Farming Guys: Farmin' In the Hood!
5 min
What the Economic Crisis Really Means, and What We Can Do About It
12 min
Like us on Facebook?
Smith: Indy Should Favor Gardeners in Clash over Urban farms