Indianapolis, IN - Events Local News Groups Contact
'Intentional misuse' of federal economic development money found in Indiana
'Intentional misuse' of federal economic development money found in Indiana
By Chris Sikich /

Federal auditors say Indiana intentionally misused federal funds when one of its contractors, operating with little state oversight, funneled nearly a half million dollars to a start-up business run by the nonprofit's chairman.

Elevate Ventures, which was the subject of anIndianapolis Star investigation last year, was hired by the state to manage millions of dollars in state and federal investment funds. The federal audit concluded that the nonprofit should not have awarded $499,986 in federal cash to a start-up business called Smarter Remarketer managed by the firm's chairman, Howard Bates.

The audit was performed by the Department of Treasury's Office of Inspector General. The treasury department said it would recoup the misused funds from the state by withholding future small-business development payments. State officials, however, say they've already repaid federal funds, with interest, and taken action to ensure better oversight.

INVESTIGATION: IEDC contractor steers Indiana investment funds to firms run by its chairman and his son

EXCLUSIVE: FSSA chief clashes over timing of Pence health insurance plan

It's the first time since the federally-funded State Small Business Credit Initiative was founded in 2010 that an audit has found money was misused intentionally, said Debra Ritt, the special deputy inspector general who oversaw the audit.

The federal probe was triggered by last year's Star investigation, which revealed Elevate Ventures steered $800,000 in taxpayer money to businesses run by its founder and his son.

The audit found that $300,000 Elevate Ventures invested in a company called MaxTradeIn in which Bates is an investor did not violate federal rules. But it "created the appearance of potential nepotism," since Bates' son, Justin, was the company's chief executive officer.

Mike Davidson, an Elevate Ventures board member, said in a statement to The Star that the nonprofit has worked with the Indiana Economic Development Corporation to improve its policies and procedures and "will continue to move forward to support Hoosier entrepreneurs and strengthen Indiana's economy."

Ritt said "it would behoove the state" to provide greater oversight of its contractors to avoid such problems in the future. Since 2011, the IEDC has dispersed $21 million in federal funds from the U.S. Treasury's State Small Business Credit Initiative.

"This is a situation where the state had relied on Elevate Ventures to manage the money to oversee how it was spent and comply with program rules, but it didn't do much oversight itself of the contractor," Ritt said in an interview Thursday. "There's lots of opportunities for conflicts of interest when you're dealing with venture capital funds."

But she added that Indiana officials appear to have taken steps to address these problems.

Gov. Mike Pence agreed.

"This matter is closed," Pence said in a statement. "The investment has been fully recovered with a 15-percent return, and following the independent review I ordered last year, Elevate and the (IEDC) both have put in place new policies and practices that will ensure funds are used appropriately in the future."

Bates, who resigned from Elevate Ventures in December, referred questions to Elevate Ventures and the IEDC.

"The IEDC will continue to work collaboratively with the U.S. Treasury in order to maintain compliance," said IEDC spokeswoman Katelyn Hancock. "Months ago, proactively and voluntarily, the IEDC and Elevate Ventures implemented standards that go above and beyond the recommendations included in the OIG report."

Indiana House Minority Leader Scott Pelath, D-Michigan City, said that state Democrats believe Republicans are using the IEDC to funnel taxpayer funds into private businesses with little accountability for how the money is spent and how many jobs are actually created.

"The IEDC in recent years has been about buddies passing around money to each other," Pelath said. "It's been about coming up with ridiculous job projections that amount to propaganda, and it's been about making sure that political powerhouses can get in at company ribbon cuttings."

The inspector general further recommended that the IEDC review every investment decision by Elevate Ventures going forward. In a response to the auditors' findings, state officials and federal treasury officials agreed to the recommendation.

But Indiana officials, as well as treasury officials who oversee the small-business initiative, disagreed with the audit's assertion that the funding was intentionally misused.

Instead, Eric Doden, the president of the IEDC, wrote in a response to the audit that the agency "did not intentionally misuse" the funds, but had merely made a "reasonable interpretation of an ambiguous regulatory requirement." Doden wrote the IEDC also had taken "extraordinary, voluntary steps to address compliance" following this "singular event that has not occurred in any prior or subsequent" use of the federal funds.

Treasury officials in their response to the audit said they didn't think the state knowingly broke program rules.

Davidson, the Elevate Ventures board member, said he agreed with state officials and the Treasury that the inspector general's "characterization of this investment is inaccurate." The inspector general is an independent government auditor within the larger Treasury Department.

In November, KPMG, the auditing firm Pence's office hired to perform an independent audit, determined the state should have had stronger oversight over Elevate Ventures but was "substantially compliant" with its own policies, federal guidance and state law.

Doden warned that the federal audit's claims of "intentional misconduct" will have a "substantial chilling effect" on the use of the job-creation money in the future.

But Ritt in her report said that "by his own statements" Bates knew "his ownership interest was an issue." She wrote that he also used the $500,000 that had not yet been awarded to make it appear his ownership interest in Smarter Remarketer was small enough to meet federal requirements.

Ritt wrote: "We believe the facts speak for themselves."

0.0 ·
What's Next
Trending Today
Noam Chomsky Has 'Never Seen Anything Like This'
Chris Hedges · 27,131 views today · Noam Chomsky is America’s greatest intellectual. His massive body of work, which includes nearly 100 books, has for decades deflated and exposed the lies of the power elite...
For Those Who Don't Want to Vote for the Lesser of Two Evils
Peter White · 16,775 views today · Ranked-choice voting is catching on, and Maine might become the first state to help citizens vote for candidates they actually want.
Your Lifestyle Has Already Been Designed (The Real Reason For The Forty-Hour Workweek)
David Cain · 11,231 views today · Well I’m in the working world again. I’ve found myself a well-paying gig in the engineering industry, and life finally feels like it’s returning to normal after my nine months...
Anarchists - What We Stand For
unknown · 11,072 views today · Anarchism : The word “anarchy” comes from Greek and means “no rulers”. As a political philosophy, anarchism is based on the idea that organization does not require rulers—that...
10 Quotes From an Oglala Lakota Chief That Will Make You Question Everything About Our Society
Wisdom Pills · 9,226 views today · Luther Standing Bear was an Oglala Lakota Sioux Chief who, among a few rare others such as Charles Eastman, Black Elk and Gertrude Bonnin occupied the rift between the way of...
HyperNormalisation (2016)
161 min · 7,729 views today · We live in a time of great uncertainty and confusion. Events keep happening that seem inexplicable and out of control. Donald Trump, Brexit, the War in Syria, the endless...
Donald and Hobbes Is Genius
Various · 4,895 views today · Some clever folk have been replacing precocious 6-year-old Calvin, from the Calvin and Hobbes comic strips, with Donald Trump and the results are, well, take a look...
Our Obsession With 'Good Immigrants' Breeds Intolerance
2 min · 3,298 views today · Society sets the bar so high to become a 'good immigrant', argues writer Nikesh Shukla, that normal immigrants are demonised. He says non-Brits in the public eye have a simple...
My Cuba - An Intimate Look at the Pleasures and Struggles of 6 Different People's Cuba
150 min · 2,181 views today · Cuba - diverse, vibrant and complex - is undergoing immense change. But what does it mean to be Cuban in this time of change? Six people. Six films. From the comedy and ballet...
Today I Rise: This Beautiful Short Film Is Like a Love Poem For Your Heart and Soul
4 min · 1,844 views today · "The world is missing what I am ready to give: My Wisdom, My Sweetness, My Love and My hunger for Peace." "Where are you? Where are you, little girl with broken wings but full...
Bird Watching on Lesvos Island - A Poetic Call to Stand With Refugees
3 min · 1,609 views today · Born in Darfur, Sudan and raised in Philadelphia, Emi Mahmoud is the 2015 World Poetry Slam Champion and the Women of the World co-Champion of 2016. From a young age Emi...
Gil Scott-Heron Deconstructs Colonialism and Black History in His Own Unique Style
3 min · 1,558 views today · His-Story: I was wondering about our yesterdays, and starting searching through the rubble and to say the very least, somebody went to a hell of a lot of trouble to make sure...
Donald Trump Is the Mirror and Hillary Clinton Is the Mask
Chris Agnos · 1,353 views today · Disclaimer: I do not support Donald Trump or Hillary Clinton for president. I think the scope of the political debate is far too narrow for the kinds of actions that need to...
The Important Difference Between Love and Being Loved
2 min · 1,352 views today · We talk of love as if it were just one thing: in fact, it’s two very different moves, Loving and Being Loved. You start to grow up when you stop focusing on the latter and get...
Planet Earth II Could Be Best Nature Doc Ever Made
3 min · 1,228 views today · 10 years ago Planet Earth changed our view of the world. Now we take you closer than ever before. This is life in all its wonder. This is Planet Earth II. A decade ago, the...
The Untold History of Palestine & Israel
22 min · 1,064 views today · Previewing Abby Martin’s on-the-ground investigation in Palestine, The Empire Files looks at the long history of Zionist colonization, expansion and expulsion of Palestine’s...
Introversion Is Not a Personality Fail
Cat Elz · 1,049 views today · A few years ago, I got into an argument with my now mother-in-law over my supposedly “backwards” ways. My transgression? I did not attend a party of my now husband’s (then...
Lessons in the Calais Jungle: Teaching Life Stories and Learning About Humanity
Aura Lounasmaa · 1,000 views today · I am part of a team of academics teaching a course to residents in the Calais Jungle, a camp for migrants and refugees outside the French city. Life Stories in the Jungle has...
What Makes Call-Out Culture So Toxic
Asam Ahmad · 877 views today · Call-out culture refers to the tendency among progressives, radicals, activists, and community organizers to publicly name instances or patterns of oppressive behaviour and...
Alliance of 600,000 British Doctors Calls for 'Imperative' Coal Phase-Out
Nadia Prupis · 790 views today · Doing so would constitute 'double win for tackling the twin health threats of air pollution and climate change,' report states
Load More
Like us on Facebook?
'Intentional misuse' of federal economic development money found in Indiana