Indianapolis, IN - Events Local News Groups Contact
Appeals court orders state to recognize one same-sex marriage
Appeals court orders state to recognize one same-sex marriage
By Tim Evans / indystar.com

The U.S. 7th Circuit Court of Appeals has ordered the state to recognize the same-sex marriage of one Hoosier couple.

The decision marks the latest development in a week of court rulings that legalized same-sex marriage in Indiana before banning it again three days later.

Tuesday's ruling came at the request of Amy Sandler and Niki Quasney, who is terminally ill. They are among the couples who had filed lawsuits earlier this year challenging the state law than bans same-sex marriage and the recognition of gay marriages conducted legally in other states.

A three-judge panel from the federal appeals court in Chicago ordered the unique recognition for the Munster couple a day after it announced plans to expedite the appeal of U.S. District Judge Richard Young's ruling last week that found Indiana's ban unconstitutional.

Carl Tobias, a University of Richmond School of Law professor who has been tracking same-sex marriage legal cases across the country, said this is the first case he is aware of in which a federal appeals court has ordered a state to recognize the marriage of a gay couple while an appeal is pending.

Since December, federal judges have struck down laws similar to Indiana's ban in more than 10 other states, and those cases are now being appealed.

This isn't the first time that Sandler and Quasney have had the distinction of being the only gay couple in Indiana to have their marriage legally acknowledged by the state.

In April, Young issued an emergency order requiring the state to recognize the couple's marriage last year in Massachusetts. But that recognition ended late Friday, when a panel from the 7th Circuit ordered a stay of Young's ruling last week while the state appeals his decision.

"It is time for the state of Indiana to leave Niki and Amy in peace and not subject them and their marriage to any more stress and uncertainty as this case proceeds," said Paul D. Castillo, staff attorney for Lambda Legal, a national gay-rights legal firm that represented the couple in its lawsuit against the state.

"We're thrilled that the court ruled in favor of this family as Niki battles stage four ovarian cancer. We will continue to fight until no family in Indiana needs to worry about their marriage being stripped away from them and all Hoosiers have the freedom to marry."

The couple had argued that lack of recognition for their marriage would endanger Sandler's ability to collect Social Security and other death benefits. Quasney was diagnosed with ovarian cancer five years ago and has since gone through chemotherapy. The couple's two daughters, ages 1 and 3, are Sandler's biological children.

UNCERTAIN FUTURE: What now for those in same-sex marriage limbo?

WEDDINGS STOP: Indiana attorney general appeals ruling

Sandler told The Indianapolis Star that she and Quasney were pleased with Tuesday's ruling but wish it applied to all same-sex couples.

"It means a lot to Niki and I that the panel of judges took the time to read about — carefully read about — our situation and realize that our marriage doesn't harm anybody in the state of Indiana," Sandler said.

"Protecting our marriage helps us, but also, we're only one family in Indiana. There are other families that are facing hardships just like us, and we're looking forward to the day when everyone has their marriage recognized in the state."

Attorneys from Lambda Legal had filed a request Monday seeking an emergency order granting the couple recognition. A spokeswoman criticized Attorney General Greg Zoeller, who is leading Indiana's push to overturn Young's ruling.

"Attorney General Zoeller's callous disregard for this family's circumstances is heartless, cruel, and unbecoming of a public official charged with representing the interests of all Hoosiers," Camilla Taylor said. "He is taking steps that no other attorney general anywhere in the country has in fighting to deny respect to the marriage of only one couple facing very significant health issues."

Zoeller's office issued a statement Tuesday indicating he sympathized with the couple and wished there was some wiggle room under the law to help them.

"The state has extensively researched this matter and sincerely wishes it found a provision within our state's statutes that would allow for some extraordinary relief or humanitarian exception to the rule of law that would grant what petitioners request," Zoeller said. "If this court can find an exception that would apply, this circumstance surely warrants its use."

Spokeswoman Staci Schneider said the attorney general's office respects the court's ruling in this matter and would have no further comment at this time.

The decision to expedite the appeal issued late Monday will speed up the process by about six weeks, with the final deadline for filing documents moved from Sept. 19 to Aug. 5.

Tobias, the law professor tracking same-sex marriage cases in federal courts across the U.S., said the appeals court order to grant recognition to Sandler and Quasney is not necessarily an indication of how the court will rule in the appeal.

"I thought they made a very persuasive argument," he said, "but I guess I would not read too much into it. It seems like the just and fair result to this one couple involved. Even a judge who thought that a ban should be upheld might find an exception justified in this particular case."

He did say, however, that Judge Young's earlier order, which had granted recognition of their marriage, may have helped sway the appellate panel.

"Why deny it to them?" he noted.

The appellate court's decision to expedite the case could be more significant, Tobias said.

He said the 7th Circuit will probably be the fourth appeals court to rule on the issue. That could put it in the mix with others for Supreme Court review.

"If the 7th Circuit were to issue (its opinion) after too many others or after too much time had passed, the opinion may miss out on being the one reviewed," he said.

Star reporters Jill Disis and Kristine Guerra contributed to this story. Call Star reporter Tim Evans at (317) 444-6204. Follow him on Twitter: @starwatchtim.

0.0 ·
0
What's Next
Trending Today
Have You Heard of The Great Forgetting? It Happened 10,000 Years Ago & Completely Affects Your Life
Daniel Quinn · 15,490 views today · (Excerpted from the book, The Story of B) With every audience and every individual, I have to begin by making them see that the cultural self-awareness we inherit from our...
The Myth of Positivity: Why Your Pain Holds a Mighty Purpose
umair haque · 14,519 views today · Of all the great myths of contemporary life, one of the most toxic is positivity. It says: there are negative and positive emotions, and only the positive ones are worth...
A Hauntingly Beautiful Short Film About Life and Death
5 min · 9,767 views today · The Life of Death is a touching handdrawn animation about the day Death fell in love with Life.
10 Stunning Images from the Wildlife Photographer of the Year People's Choice Award
Natural History Museum · 8,919 views today · These incredible images are a selection from of the 25 shortlisted by The Natural History Museum for the People's Choice Award from this year's Wildlife Photographer of the...
Seven Must-Have Skills for the 21st Century
Tommy Lehe · 7,283 views today · We live in a world that moves faster than we do. Trying to keep up can be an overwhelming task that at times feels hopeless, like we are falling further and further behind—but...
Forget Air Force One, Pentagon Wastes Billions and Billions Every Month
Nadia Prupis · 4,951 views today · President-elect Donald Trump's focus on single Boeing contract ignores enormous waste of bloated Pentagon budget
Stunning Summary of US Imperialism and Native Resistance... on MSNBC!
4 min · 4,105 views today · On The Last Word with Lawrence O'Donnell on MSNBC, Lawrence explains why a protest by Native Americans in North Dakota reminds us of the history American always tries to forget.
DREAM: A Spoken Word Meditation For When Life Is Kicking Your Ass
4 min · 2,478 views today · If life is kicking your ass and the general un-coolness of everybody on planet erf is making you want to off yourself, TALK to someone: 800-273-8255 (national suicide...
Standing Rock Wisdom: How Sacred, Nonviolent Activism Has the Power to Succeed
Charles Eisenstein · 2,088 views today · I am told by Native American friends active at Standing Rock that the elders are counseling the Water Protectors to undertake each action prayerfully and to stay off the...
Amanda Abbington Introduces iAnimal - 42 Days in the Life of Chickens
4 min · 2,041 views today · Shot undercover in British factory farms and slaughterhouses, this immersive 360° video gives you a birds-eye view of what happens to chicken from farm to plate.
The Other Way of Knowing
Lilian Na’ia Alessa · 1,988 views today · Western science and Indigenous worldviews are often seen as incompatible, with the Indigenous view usually being far less valued by society at large. But an inside look at...
The Most Powerful Algorithm in the World
Joe Brewer · 1,976 views today · After the insanity of the U.S. election, a lot of people are blaming Facebook for its algorithms that parse us into ideological bubbles and spread “fake news” and other kinds...
Veterans at Standing Rock Ask Forgiveness for War Crimes Against Tribal Nations
Jen Hayden · 1,687 views today · Jon Eagle Sr., Tribal Historic Preservation Officer at Standing Rock Sioux Tribe has reported something wholly unexpected happened at the Standing Rock Reservation today. The...
How a White Supremacist Became a Civil Rights Activist
Araz Hachadourian · 1,634 views today · The story of a KKK leader’s transformation shows us that we need not live forever with the kind of violence we saw in Charleston this month.
Dear Activists, Maybe It's Time to Admit That We've Got It All Wrong
Mickey Z. · 1,422 views today · “The first step in the revolution is eye contact.” - Alicen Grey
Sean Carroll - The Meaning of Life
7 min · 1,365 views today · The world keeps happening in accordance with its rules; it's up to us to make sense of it and give it value. Sean Carroll Music: Moby - God Moving Over the Face of the Waters
What Makes Call-Out Culture So Toxic
Asam Ahmad · 1,335 views today · Call-out culture refers to the tendency among progressives, radicals, activists, and community organizers to publicly name instances or patterns of oppressive behaviour and...
Solar is Already Producing More Energy Than Oil, Says Major Scientific Review
Nafeez Ahmed · 1,302 views today · And is twice as powerful than previously thought
Why People Cling to Old Beliefs
1 min · 1,292 views today · Cognitive psychologist and neuroscientist at McGill University, Daniel Levitin, explains why people can be so stubborn when it comes to false beliefs. This behavior is...
The 24-Hour Emergency Hotline for Syrian Refugees
7 min · 1,117 views today · Mohammed Abu Amar runs a makeshift 24-hour helpline from his flat in Hamburg, guiding scared refugees fleeing the violence in Syria across the water to Europe.  Despite losing...
Load More
Like us on Facebook?
Appeals court orders state to recognize one same-sex marriage