Indianapolis, IN - Events Local News Groups Contact
Appeals court orders state to recognize one same-sex marriage
Appeals court orders state to recognize one same-sex marriage
By Tim Evans / indystar.com
Jul 2, 2014

The U.S. 7th Circuit Court of Appeals has ordered the state to recognize the same-sex marriage of one Hoosier couple.

The decision marks the latest development in a week of court rulings that legalized same-sex marriage in Indiana before banning it again three days later.

Tuesday's ruling came at the request of Amy Sandler and Niki Quasney, who is terminally ill. They are among the couples who had filed lawsuits earlier this year challenging the state law than bans same-sex marriage and the recognition of gay marriages conducted legally in other states.

A three-judge panel from the federal appeals court in Chicago ordered the unique recognition for the Munster couple a day after it announced plans to expedite the appeal of U.S. District Judge Richard Young's ruling last week that found Indiana's ban unconstitutional.

Carl Tobias, a University of Richmond School of Law professor who has been tracking same-sex marriage legal cases across the country, said this is the first case he is aware of in which a federal appeals court has ordered a state to recognize the marriage of a gay couple while an appeal is pending.

Since December, federal judges have struck down laws similar to Indiana's ban in more than 10 other states, and those cases are now being appealed.

This isn't the first time that Sandler and Quasney have had the distinction of being the only gay couple in Indiana to have their marriage legally acknowledged by the state.

In April, Young issued an emergency order requiring the state to recognize the couple's marriage last year in Massachusetts. But that recognition ended late Friday, when a panel from the 7th Circuit ordered a stay of Young's ruling last week while the state appeals his decision.

"It is time for the state of Indiana to leave Niki and Amy in peace and not subject them and their marriage to any more stress and uncertainty as this case proceeds," said Paul D. Castillo, staff attorney for Lambda Legal, a national gay-rights legal firm that represented the couple in its lawsuit against the state.

"We're thrilled that the court ruled in favor of this family as Niki battles stage four ovarian cancer. We will continue to fight until no family in Indiana needs to worry about their marriage being stripped away from them and all Hoosiers have the freedom to marry."

The couple had argued that lack of recognition for their marriage would endanger Sandler's ability to collect Social Security and other death benefits. Quasney was diagnosed with ovarian cancer five years ago and has since gone through chemotherapy. The couple's two daughters, ages 1 and 3, are Sandler's biological children.

UNCERTAIN FUTURE: What now for those in same-sex marriage limbo?

WEDDINGS STOP: Indiana attorney general appeals ruling

Sandler told The Indianapolis Star that she and Quasney were pleased with Tuesday's ruling but wish it applied to all same-sex couples.

"It means a lot to Niki and I that the panel of judges took the time to read about — carefully read about — our situation and realize that our marriage doesn't harm anybody in the state of Indiana," Sandler said.

"Protecting our marriage helps us, but also, we're only one family in Indiana. There are other families that are facing hardships just like us, and we're looking forward to the day when everyone has their marriage recognized in the state."

Attorneys from Lambda Legal had filed a request Monday seeking an emergency order granting the couple recognition. A spokeswoman criticized Attorney General Greg Zoeller, who is leading Indiana's push to overturn Young's ruling.

"Attorney General Zoeller's callous disregard for this family's circumstances is heartless, cruel, and unbecoming of a public official charged with representing the interests of all Hoosiers," Camilla Taylor said. "He is taking steps that no other attorney general anywhere in the country has in fighting to deny respect to the marriage of only one couple facing very significant health issues."

Zoeller's office issued a statement Tuesday indicating he sympathized with the couple and wished there was some wiggle room under the law to help them.

"The state has extensively researched this matter and sincerely wishes it found a provision within our state's statutes that would allow for some extraordinary relief or humanitarian exception to the rule of law that would grant what petitioners request," Zoeller said. "If this court can find an exception that would apply, this circumstance surely warrants its use."

Spokeswoman Staci Schneider said the attorney general's office respects the court's ruling in this matter and would have no further comment at this time.

The decision to expedite the appeal issued late Monday will speed up the process by about six weeks, with the final deadline for filing documents moved from Sept. 19 to Aug. 5.

Tobias, the law professor tracking same-sex marriage cases in federal courts across the U.S., said the appeals court order to grant recognition to Sandler and Quasney is not necessarily an indication of how the court will rule in the appeal.

"I thought they made a very persuasive argument," he said, "but I guess I would not read too much into it. It seems like the just and fair result to this one couple involved. Even a judge who thought that a ban should be upheld might find an exception justified in this particular case."

He did say, however, that Judge Young's earlier order, which had granted recognition of their marriage, may have helped sway the appellate panel.

"Why deny it to them?" he noted.

The appellate court's decision to expedite the case could be more significant, Tobias said.

He said the 7th Circuit will probably be the fourth appeals court to rule on the issue. That could put it in the mix with others for Supreme Court review.

"If the 7th Circuit were to issue (its opinion) after too many others or after too much time had passed, the opinion may miss out on being the one reviewed," he said.

Star reporters Jill Disis and Kristine Guerra contributed to this story. Call Star reporter Tim Evans at (317) 444-6204. Follow him on Twitter: @starwatchtim.

0.0 ·
0
Trending Today
Obama's Hidden Role in Worsening Climate Change
Stansfield Smith · 9,195 views today · It should be a scandal that leftists-liberals paint Trump as a special threat, a war mongerer – not Obama who is the first president to be at war everyday of his eight years...
The Top 100 Documentaries We Can Use to Change the World
Films For Action · 4,649 views today · A more beautiful, just and sustainable world is possible. Take this library and use it to inspire global change!
Make The Serengeti Great Again | Resource Scarcity, Demagogues and How Creativity Can Trump Hate (2017)
5 min · 2,455 views today · A Familiar Tale of Resource Scarcity, Demagogues, and How Creativity Can Trump Hate A quick, original, illustrated allegory that pokes at the demagogues we’ve got with an...
John Lennon's "Imagine," Made Into a Comic Strip
John Lennon. Art by Pablo Stanley · 1,958 views today · This is easily the best comic strip ever made.  Pabl
Baraka (1992)
97 min · 1,792 views today · Featuring no conventional narrative, this film presents footage of people, places and things from around the world. From chaotic cities to barren wilderness, the movie takes...
What Is a Gift Economy? - Alex Gendler
4 min · 1,211 views today · What if, this holiday season, instead of saying "thank you" to your aunt for her gift of a knitted sweater, the polite response expected from you was to show up at her house in...
Deconstructing Hierarchies: On Contrived Leadership and Arbitrary Positions of Power
Colin Jenkins · 1,178 views today · Bosses don't grow on trees. They don't magically appear at your job. They aren't born into their roles. They are created. They are manufactured to fulfill arbitrary positions...
Today I Rise: This Beautiful Short Film Is Like a Love Poem For Your Heart and Soul
4 min · 1,062 views today · "The world is missing what I am ready to give: My Wisdom, My Sweetness, My Love and My hunger for Peace." "Where are you? Where are you, little girl with broken wings but full...
Union Co-Operatives: What They Are and Why We Need Them
Simon Taylor · 905 views today · Neoliberal policies contribute to alienation, disempowerment and non-unionised jobs, but a new model for unions could break the vicious circle, argues Simon Taylor.
Why I Think This World Should End
4 min · 781 views today · Sorry if this offends you. - Prince Ea
How Mindfulness Empowers Us
2 min · 653 views today · Many traditions speak of the opposing forces within us, vying for our attention. Native American stories speak of two wolves, the angry wolf and the loving wolf, who both live...
The Myth of Romantic Love May Be Ruining Your Health
Susanne Vosmer · 416 views today · Romantic love in Western societies is often portrayed in a stereotypical way: two yearning halves, who search for each other to find their complete, original state. Few find...
Prophecy Delivered! Martin Luther King Jr. and the Death of Democracy
Reverend Osagyefo Sekou · 407 views today · “A nation that continues year after year to spend more money on military defense than on programs of social uplift is approaching spiritual death.” Democracy is dead. It...
Trump: The Illusion of Change
Helena Norberg-Hodge · 341 views today · “Only by restoring the broken connections can we be healed.” — Wendell Berry
Bertrand Russell & Buckminster Fuller on Why We Should Work Less, and Live & Learn More
Josh Jones · 321 views today · Why must we all work long hours to earn the right to live? Why must only the wealthy have a access to leisure, aesthetic pleasure, self-actualization…? Everyone seems to have...
Dinosaur explains Trump policies better than Trump!
8 min · 312 views today · Donald Trump is actually the corporate triceratops, Mr. Richfield, from the 90's TV show sitcom, "Dinosaurs". 
Why It's Crucial for Women to Heal the Mother Wound
Bethany Webster · 294 views today · The issue at the core of women’s empowerment is the mother wound
Forget Shorter Showers: Why Personal Change Does Not Equal Political Change (2015)
11 min · 272 views today · Would any sane person think dumpster diving would have stopped Hitler, or that composting would have ended slavery or brought about the eight-hour workday; or that chopping...
Trump Is a Symptom of a Sickness That Is Raging All Across The World
1 min · 244 views today · This is why we are here. And this is what we need to remember. 
Meet the New Boss, Same as the Old Boss: Bracing for Trump's Anti-Worker, Corporate Agenda
Colin Jenkins · 212 views today · Rich people don’t have to have a life-and-death relationship with the truth and its questions; they can ignore the truth and still thrive materially. I am not surprised many...
Load More
What's Next
Like us on Facebook?
Appeals court orders state to recognize one same-sex marriage