The Guy Who Gave Us "I Heart NY" Has a Depressing New Logo for Our Dying planet
By Lindsay Abrams / salon.com
Aug 10, 2014

Milton Glaser is famous for uniting New Yorkers under the simple, iconic “I Heart New York” logo. (He also designed the label for Brooklyn Brewery and, as I learned on a recent tour, had the good sense to emphasize the beer’s borough of origin back before it was cool.) Now, at age 85, he’s out to rebrand the climate movement. The pitch: a hazy black circle with just a small band of green (read: Earth), which people can purchase and wear as a button. In a poster hung on the exterior of the New York School of Visual Arts‘ East 23rd Street building, the logo is accompanied by the slogan “It’s not warming, it’s dying.”

The obvious problem, right off the bat, is that Earth is warming: It’s done so rapidly over the 20th century, and is expected to continue at an even faster rate over the next 100 years. The world’s governments agreed that we should try to limit warming to below 2 degrees Celsius (3.6 degrees Fahrenheit) above pre-industrial levels to try to avoid the worst consequences of that warming, yet we’re on track to blow right past that limit. While Glaser obviously agrees that this is a problem, the slogan obscures that point. And as someone attuned to the world of climate deniers, I can’t help thinking that getting the hashtag #itsnotwarming to go viral might not have the intended effect.

(Also, as Fast Co.Exist points out, it’s not the planet that’s at risk of dying — it’s us.)

But those are technicalities. Glaser told WNYC’s Brain Lehrer that his problem with the word “warming” is that it “sounds reassuring and comforting.” So if your complaint is that the slogan sounds overly pessimistic, well, that’s kind of the point. “Either Earth is dying or it’s beginning to grow again,” Glaser explained. “My preference would be that it was beginning to grow again, but for the moment I have no evidence of that.”

He’s puzzled, he continued, by the way that climate negativity is rejected by people who, out of self-interest, would rather think everything is going to be fine; he argues that we need more negativity to drive home the fact that, barring a collective effort to change our greenhouse gas-emitting ways, it might not be.

Meanwhile, it’s not the slogan but the image, he said, that’s the most important part of the campaign: people have suggested that the black could represent oil, or pollution, or death, but he sees it as symbolizing “the end of green.” Wearing the button is an acknowledgment that this is happening, he said, and “the acknowledgment itself produces change.” If enough people openly sport their concern, in other words, maybe the people in power will no longer be able to deny that this is something to be concerned about.

Coming as it is from a very dark place, Glaser intends the message to galvanize. The trick is just  to do that without inadvertently inducing defeatism instead. ”If one is looking for a purpose and theme to their life,” he told Dezeen, “avoiding the worst event in human history is a good place to begin.” That’s slightly more inspiring, at least, than announcing that we might be fucked.

 Lindsay Abrams is a staff writer at Salon, reporting on all things sustainable. Follow her on Twitter @readingirl, email labrams@salon.com

3.5 ·
1

Support Films For Action

Films For Action empowers citizens with the information they need to help create a more just, sustainable, and democratic society.

We receive no government or corporate funding and rely on our supporters to keep us going. ​

Donate today

 

Join Team Transition

Create an account on Films For Action and join our growing community of people who want to change the world!

Add videos, articles and more. Rate member content. Our library is powered by you.

Trending Today
What If Everything You Knew About Disciplining Kids Was Wrong?
Katherine Reynolds Lewis4,343 views today ·
How Swedes and Norwegians Broke the Power of the ‘1 Percent’
George Lakey4,178 views today ·
Cultural Appropriation: Whose Culture Is It Anyway, and What About Hybridity?
Sonny Hallett2,039 views today ·
The Silencing of Dissent
Chris Hedges1,075 views today ·
Deliver Us From Venus and Mars: Why Aren’t We Free From Gender Stereotypes Yet?
Gavin Evans1,067 views today ·
Don’t Be Scared About the End of Capitalism—Be Excited to Build What Comes Next
Jason Hickel and Martin Kirk929 views today ·
This Facebook Comment About the UK Election Is Going Viral
Chris Renwick922 views today ·
Have You Heard of The Great Forgetting? It Happened 10,000 Years Ago & Completely Affects Your Life
Daniel Quinn866 views today ·
Elder Explains the Origins of the First Nation Seven Teachings
11 min811 views today ·
Load More
Join us on Facebook
The Guy Who Gave Us "I Heart NY" Has a Depressing New Logo for Our Dying planet