So That's Why They Kept the Drone Kill Memo Secret
So That's Why They Kept the Drone Kill Memo Secret
By David Swanson / commondreams.org
Jun 29, 2014

Now that the U.S. government has released parts of its We-Can-Kill-People-With-Drones memo, it's hard to miss why it was kept secret until now.

Liberal professors and human rights groups and the United Nations were claiming an inability to know whether drone murders were legal or not because they hadn't seen the memo that the White House said legalized them. Some may continue to claim that the redactions in the memo make judgment impossible.

I expect most, however, will now be willing to drop the pretense that ANY memo could possibly legalize murder. 

Oh, and yall can stop telling me not to use the impolite term "murder" to describe the, you know, murders -- since "murder" is precisely the term used by the no-longer secret memo.

The memo considers a section of the U.S. code dealing with the murder of a U.S. citizen by another U.S. citizen abroad, drawing on another section that defines murder as "the unlawful killing of a human being with malice aforethought."

David Barron, the memo's author, needed a loophole to make murder-by-missile a lawfulkilling rather than an unlawful killing, so he pulls out the "public authority justification" under which the government gets to use force to enforce a law.  It's a novel twist, though, for the government to get to use force to violate the law, claiming the violation is legal on the Nixonian basis that it is the government doing it.

Alternatively, Barron suggests, a government gets to use force if doing so is part of a war. This, of course, ignores the U.N. Charter and the Kellogg Briand Pact and the illegality of wars, as well as the novelty of claiming that a war exists everywhere on earth forever and ever. (None of Barron's arguments justify governmental murder on U.S. soil any less than off U.S. soil.)

In essence, Barron seems to argue, the people who wrote the laws were thinking about private citizens and terrorists, not the government (which, somehow, cannot be a terrorist), and therefore it's OK for the government to violate the laws.

Then there's the problem of Congressional authorization of war, or lack thereof, which Barron gets around by pretending that the Authorization for the Use of Military Force was as broad as the White House pretends rather than worded to allow targeting only those responsible for the 911 attacks. 

Then there are the facts of the matter in the case of Anwar al Awlaki, who was targeted for murder prior in time to the actions that President Obama has claimed justified that targeting.

Then there are the facts in the other cases of U.S. killings of U.S. citizens, which aren't even redacted, as they're never considered.

Then there are the vastly more numerous killings of non-U.S. citizens, which the memo does not even attempt to excuse.

In the end, the memo admits that calling something a war isn't good enough; the targeted victim has to have been an imminent threat to the United States.  But who gets to decide whether he or she was that?  Why, whoever does the killing of course.  And what happens if nobody ever even makes an unsupported assertion to that effect? Nothing, of course.

This is not the rule of law.  This is savage brute force in minimal disguise.  I don't want to see any more of these memos.  I want to see the video footage of the drone murders on a television.  I want to see law professors and revolving-door State Department / human rights group hacks argue that dead children fall under the public authority justification.

3.5 ·
1
Trending Today
The Top 100 Documentaries We Can Use to Change the World
Films For Action9,991 views today ·
The Western Idea of Private Property Is Flawed. Indigenous Peoples Have It Right
Julian Brave Noisecat3,545 views today ·
Occupy Your Brain: On Power, Knowledge, and the Re-Occupation of Common Sense
Carol Black2,845 views today ·
Pope Francis on Why the Only Future Worth Building Includes Everyone
18 min1,860 views today ·
17 Films That Make It Very Clear Our Economic System Is Killing the Planet
Tim Hjersted1,697 views today ·
Get Out of the Materialism Trap NOW
10 min1,359 views today ·
You Don't Publish a Million Secrets a Year Without Making a Few Enemies
2 min1,288 views today ·
Temporary Truce in a Democratic Party Civil War: The Sanders & Perez Unity Tour
16 min1,264 views today ·
25 Cheat Sheets for Taking Care of Yourself Like a Damn Adult
Anna Borges1,088 views today ·
Load More
What's Next
The Elephant In The Room
92 min
Big Bucks, Big Pharma: Marketing Disease and Pushing Drugs (2006)
68 min
This is my protest
46 min
Like us on Facebook?
So That's Why They Kept the Drone Kill Memo Secret