No Tech Solutions for Poverty, Says Former Microsoft Researcher
By Amy Costello / huffingtonpost.com

I founded Tiny Spark four years ago to investigate philanthropy, nonprofits and socially responsible companies. As a former Africa correspondent, I had seen with my own eyes how difficult is it to have lasting impact in places far from where we live and discovered that well-intentioned projects can sometimes cause harm.

In our podcast, we ask critical questions of people and projects aiming to do good, so that we can figure out how to do good better. In this inaugural blog for the Huffington Post, we take a hard look at tech's promise to change the world. You can listen to the podcast here:

Our guest this week says tech alone will never solve the world's problems. Kentaro Toyama worked for Microsoft in India for five years, researching how to help the poor through tech. But after rolling out more than 50 research projects, Toyama says he's had a change of heart.

"The idea that you can spread a technology or scale a technology, as people like to say, in order to accomplish some kind of social progress is deeply misguided."

The Limits of Tech

Toyama says tech merely amplifies good and bad situations; it doesn't actually change them. For kids in decent schools with great teachers, tech makes their education better. But if you're trying to help kids where there's no running water and poorly trained teachers, Toyama says a campaign to get a computer in every classroom may actually make things worse.

"In those schools in which you don't have strong administration, good teachers and so forth, the technology will usually not have any kind of impact whatsoever, and in some cases, it can cause outright harm."

2015-08-14-1439570621-2861879-Rajasthanschoolchildren.JPG

Toyama recalls many times when he was introducing new technologies in classrooms in India with teachers who were very eager to use them. "But they would spend a good chunk of the class just setting up the technology and getting everything right. Half the class is over. And to me, that's a waste of that class time," he says. "If we didn't have the technology there, trying to run these programs, they could get on with their regular educational curriculum, and it would probably end up being better for the students."

In his book, Geek Heresy: Rescuing Social Change from the Cult of Technology, the Yale-trained computer scientist skewers all kinds of well-intentioned initiatives that have promised to level the proverbial playing field: Online education, microcredit and even the crowdfunding platform Kickstarter.

2015-08-14-1439565431-2935753-GeekHeresyFinalFrontCover_opt.jpg

Kickstarter Favors The Well-Connected

"People talk about how Kickstarter is a way to raise money and you no longer have to be a fundraising professional to be able to do it. Anybody can simply go online and raise funds from their friends," Toyama says. But he points to the fact that the average Kickstarter campaign raises less than $10,000 when it's successful. Compare that to what actor and director Zach Braff was able to bring in when he turned to the platform to raise funds for his own film. Braff took in $3 million from some 46,000 backers.

"Your existing influence and status as a celebrity gets amplified using the technology, but those gains don't necessarily apply to everybody else, to the average person. So the same technology, used by different people, has different outcomes. People with wealth or education or social influence end up benefiting much, much more from the technology than people without."

So what is needed to truly transform lives if not tech? Toyama says we must begin with humility. "One of the most misguided ways in which we do development is to assume that we who have advantages know what's good for the other person," he says. Instead, Toyama champions a proven -- if decidedly old school -- solution for transformational change: mentorship.

2015-08-14-1439570911-7607526-UgandaCommunityKnowledgeWorkers.JPG

Personal Connections Trump Tech

"The idea with mentorship is to really ask first, 'What is it that the other person aspires to? What do they most want?' And then to see if we can help. Using the advantages that we have, help them gain the skills and the resources that are required to achieve their own aspirations."

If we begin to turn away from screen-based solutions and toward one another, Toyama says global efforts to do good will still be long and hard, but ultimately more fruitful. "Many of the misguided programs that we impose on the world happen because we tend to see the world as a machine, and people as cogs in that machine. So if we find the right technology, and the right place to put the new technology, then the machine will work better. But I think ultimately that's a mistake."

Toyama has already begun to re-engineer his own career toward a more human-centered approach to doing good in the world. He says developing tech is comparatively easy. "What is much harder, and I think a much deeper problem, is: How do we spread this idea that more of us should really actively seek to be better persons for ourselves? How do we cause that social change to happen? So I focus more and more on people and on the human psychology and sociology of true human development."

4.0 ·
1
What's Next
Trending Today
Dakota Access Pipeline Permit Denied
Nika Knight · 15,016 views today · 'For the first time in Native American history, they heard our voices.'
All the News Is Fake!
3 min · 10,330 views today · Jonathan Pie finds nothing new in the idea of fake news.
How Romanticism Ruined Love
5 min · 8,890 views today · The set of ideas we can call Romanticism is responsible for making our relationships extremely difficult. We shouldn’t give up on love; we should just recognize that it’s more...
How Mindfulness Empowers Us
2 min · 6,203 views today · Many traditions speak of the opposing forces within us, vying for our attention. Native American stories speak of two wolves, the angry wolf and the loving wolf, who both live...
After Historic Protests, Army Corps of Engineers Blocks Current Route of the Dakota Access Pipeline
3 min · 3,172 views today · The $4 billion dollar project could still be approved by President-elect Donald Trump who is heavily invested in the pipeline. Help support The Real News by making a donation...
The Numbers That Tell the Story of the Standing Rock Sioux's Victory
Tracy Loeffelholz Dunn · 2,701 views today · The Army Corps announced Sunday that the Dakota Access pipeline will be rerouted. Here are the numbers that show what lies ahead.
Post-Brexit Visions of The Possible: It's Time to Imagine a New European Community
Martin Winiecki · 2,443 views today · We live in the beginning phase of a global revolution which will turn societal conditions upside down. We cannot stop this transformation, but we can influence where it will...
Bikini Was Just the Beginning, Bombs Still Threaten the Islanders
John Pilger · 2,417 views today · I was recently in the Marshall Islands, which lie in the middle of the Pacific Ocean, north of Australia and south of Hawaii. Whenever I tell people where I have been, they...
This is an Anthem for Our Times
6 min · 2,119 views today · I think the world deserves to see the truth about #NoDAPL I tried my best to portray what I felt at camp, I felt LOVE. Love for all people, all living things, Mother Earth...
93 Documentaries to Expand Your Consciousness
Films For Action · 2,109 views today · There are over 800 documentaries now cataloged in our library of social change films. That's probably way too many for any mortal to ever watch in a lifetime, let alone a few...
Lifting the Veil:  Obama and the Failure of Capitalist Democracy (2011)
114 min · 2,026 views today · This film explores the historical role of the Democratic Party as the "graveyard of social movements", the massive influence of corporate finance in elections, the absurd...
United Natures: a United Nations of all Species (2013)
103 min · 1,869 views today · United Natures explores the Rights of Mother Earth, Environmental Philosophy, Wisdom, Spirituality and the potential for a Neo-indigenous future for humanity. Directed and...
The Venus Project by Jacque Fresco
4 min · 1,462 views today · For more information visit the official web site: thevenusproject.com Facebook: facebook.com/TheVenusProjectGlobal Music: Salomon Ligthelm - Close Horizonz Hanz Zimmer ...
10 Practical Tools for Building a Resilient Local Economy
Environmental Change Makers · 1,455 views today · The economy is changing. Dramatically. Coping with these changes means changing the way we do things. The path of the future involves root level, radical changes. Things we...
Today I Rise: This Beautiful Short Film Is Like a Love Poem For Your Heart and Soul
4 min · 1,304 views today · "The world is missing what I am ready to give: My Wisdom, My Sweetness, My Love and My hunger for Peace." "Where are you? Where are you, little girl with broken wings but full...
Austrialian Government Promotes Crap with Adani Carmichael Coal Mine
2 min · 1,098 views today · The Australian Government just released this advert about the proposed Carmichael Coal Mine and it's surprisingly honest and informative. 6 WAYS YOU CAN HELP STOP CCRAP: 1...
John Lennon's "Imagine," Made Into a Comic Strip
John Lennon. Art by Pablo Stanley · 930 views today · This is easily the best comic strip ever made.  Pabl
90 Inspiring and Visionary Films That Will Change How You See the World in Profound Ways
Tim Hjersted · 900 views today · The world today is in crisis. Everybody knows that. But what is driving this crisis? It's a story, a story that is destroying the world. It's a story about our relationship to...
Why Are Media Outlets Still Citing Discredited 'Fake News' Blacklist?
Adam Johnson · 610 views today · The Washington Post (11/24/16) last week published a front-page blockbuster that quickly went viral: Russia-promoted “fake news” had infiltrated the newsfeeds of 213 million...
The Fight for Clean Water (#NoDAPL)
2 min · 566 views today · Clean water or Corporate profits? What’s more important? #NoDAPL Energy Transfer Partners: (214) 981-0700 U.S. Army Corps Of Engineers: (202) 761-0010; (202)...
Load More
Like us on Facebook?
No Tech Solutions for Poverty, Says Former Microsoft Researcher