Germany's Check on Free Speech
In the United States, hate speech is only illegal if it incites immediate violence. In Germany, however, one can serve up to five years in prison for Volksverhetzung (incitement to hatred). Is free speech an absolute, or must it be checked?
Germany's Check on Free Speech
By Greg Lepore / filmsforaction.org
Mar 20, 2016

Free speech is a staple of democracy around the world, and societies have gone to extreme lengths to keep it protected and preserved.  At times, however, these same societies have discovered that complete freedom of speech has the potential be more damaging than constructive.

            When does free speech become hate speech? This question is not easily answered, and for each person asked, a new definition of hate speech is written. One thing is for certain, though. Whether it is directed at an individual or a group of individuals, the ramifications of hate speech are far-reaching and long-lasting. The entire community is afflicted, divided, embarrassed, and damaged irreparably for the immediate future.

The American Bar Association defines hate speech as “speech that offends, threatens, or insults groups, based on race, color, religion, national origin, sexual orientation, disability, or other traits.” Other democracies define hate speech in similar terms. However, as heinous as the definition sounds, hate speech remains protected by free speech in many modern democracies.

In the United States, for example, Supreme Court rulings over the years have determined that hate speech is protected by the First Amendment so long as that speech does not incite immediate violence. To be sure, there have been segments of American society that have attempted to circumvent this legal quagmire. In the latter part of the 20th century, nearly 400 American universities adopted speech codes outlawing hate speech on their campuses. The legality of these codes has not faired well when tested in court.

In countries where hate speech has led to traumatic events, one finds that it has been completely outlawed. Germany, for example, harbors one of the world’s toughest legal codes pertaining to hate speech as a result of the country’s experience with Nazi propaganda. While not exercised often, the dominance of this legal code has entered the limelight as a result of the current refugee crisis.

Lutz Bachman, founder of the Islamophobic group Pegida, will stand trial for hate speech crimes related to a Facebook post in which he referred to Syrian refugees as “cattle” and “scum.” If convicted, Bachman could serve up to five years in prison. In Germany, Volksverhetzung (incitement to hatred) is “to publicly incite hatred against parts of the population or to call for violent or arbitrary measures against them or to insult, maliciously slur or defame them in a manner violating their (constitutionally protected) human dignity.”

Critics contend that Volksverhetzung limits free speech and therefore cannot be good for democracy. But for the majority of Germans, it is a necessary check on free speech. Today’s Germans grow up with the constant reminder of what can happen if hatred is allowed to spread throughout a country due to unchecked free speech.

Whether Volksverhetzung is a just law in a democratic society remains up for debate. Is hate speech protected by freedom of speech, or is it a perversion of one of liberty’s dearest principles? You be the judge.

0.0 ·
0
Trending Today
Bertrand Russell & Buckminster Fuller on Why We Should Work Less, and Live & Learn More
Josh Jones15,560 views today ·
The Venus Project Plans to Bring Humanity to the Next Stage of Social Evolution. Here's How.
Daniel Araya with Roxanne Meadows13,617 views today ·
Forget Shorter Showers: Why Personal Change Does Not Equal Political Change (2015)
11 min9,091 views today ·
The West Was Built on Racism. It's Time We Faced That
2 min8,923 views today ·
7 Signs of Tyranny
2 min7,327 views today ·
The Trump Report - The Real Fake News About The Dakota Access Pipeline
2 min6,126 views today ·
4.1 Miles
21 min5,709 views today ·
The Choice Between Fear And Love
5 min3,681 views today ·
What It Takes to Change Hearts and Minds
Colin Beavan3,428 views today ·
Life's Pursuit: Endlessly Seeking External Rewards is Self-Defeating
Gavin Aung Than2,509 views today ·
Why Would Any of Us Want to Live like a Savage?
Juan Pablo Quinonez1,520 views today ·
Touch Isolation: How Homophobia Has Robbed All Men Of Touch
Mark Greene1,431 views today ·
Load More
New
How the BBC Makes The Most Incredible Wildlife Films in the World
14 min
Learning to See in the Dark Amid Catastrophe: An Interview With Deep Ecologist Joanna Macy
Dahr Jamail
Beyond Trump: Rebooting the System From Inside the Death Machine
Nafeez Ahmed, with Andrew Markell and Gunther Sonnenfeld
The West Was Built on Racism. It's Time We Faced That
2 min
Chris Hedges & Abby Martin - Trump, Fascism & the Christian Right
26 min
4.1 Miles
21 min
7 Signs of Tyranny
2 min
How to Be a Great Listener
5 min
DAPL Opponents Vow to 'Rise' From Ashes of Oceti Sakowin and Keep Fighting
Lauren McCauley
Those That Did Not Seek Revenge
Dr. Ann Russo
MLK Stands With Standing Rock (#NoDAPL)
3 min
Michael Moore Wants to Help You Find Your Next Anti-Trump Protest
Sarah Ruiz-Grossman
Load More
What's Next
Best Speech You Will Ever Hear!
70 min
Democracy Needs A None Of The Above Option To Work (2014)
4 min
The Chain of Obedience
2 min
Like us on Facebook?
Germany's Check on Free Speech